Skip to content

Head to head

Marvels vs The Walking Dead

Dead level: both score 8.1. What separates them is what they are for, not how good they are.

Cover of Marvels
Marvels

1994 · Excellent

  • Alex Ross's realistic paintings make familiar heroes feel astonishing again
  • A fresh ground-level perspective on events readers know from the costumed side
  • Episodic structure means some chapters are stronger than others
Cover of The Walking Dead
The Walking Dead

2003 · Excellent

  • Follows survivors for years past where most zombie stories stop
  • Rick's evolution as a leader is gripping and morally complex
  • The cycle of settlement, threat and loss becomes repetitive

Where the gap is

Art
9.47.6
Story
7.88.2
Pacing
7.57.4
Characters
7.68.5

At a glance

FactMarvelsThe Walking Dead
Released19948 October 2003
PublisherMarvel ComicsImage Comics, Delcourt
Issues4193
GenreDrama · SuperheroDrama · Horror
Writer—Robert Kirkman

The two verdicts

Marvels

Marvels looks up at superheroes from the street, and finds awe tinged with fear

Marvels is a visually spectacular, emotionally intelligent tribute that changed how superhero history could be told. Its reliance on prior knowledge, episodic chapters and slender central character keep it from greatness as a stand-alone story. An 8.1 recognises an excellent, influential book whose art carries more than its narrative.

Read the full review →

The Walking Dead

The Walking Dead comic is a relentless, sixteen-year study of survival and power

The Walking Dead is a gripping, ambitious and influential series that turned a zombie premise into a long, meaningful exploration of human nature and society. Its repetitive structure, hard-to-distinguish characters and reliance on shock hold it back. An 8.1 reflects an excellent, landmark series whose power sometimes gets lost in its length.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.