Skip to content

Head to head

Middlemarch vs The Lord of the Rings

The Lord of the Rings takes it by 0.1, 9.6 against 9.5. The subscores below show where the gap actually is.

Cover of Middlemarch
Middlemarch

1871 · Masterpiece

  • A narrator who explains every character's motives, including the ones we dislike
  • Four interlocking plots, each strong enough to carry a shorter novel alone
  • The first hundred pages ask for patience before the town comes into focus
Cover of The Lord of the Rings
The Lord of the Rings

1954 · Masterpiece

  • Middle-earth's languages, histories and geography give it unmatched depth
  • Sam and Frodo's friendship is one of fiction's great depictions of loyalty
  • The long opening in the Shire and Old Forest tests newcomers' patience

Where the gap is

Ideas
9.69.7
Story
9.09.6
Writing
9.79.1
Characters
9.89.0

At a glance

FactMiddlemarchThe Lord of the Rings
Released187129 July 1954
AuthorGeorge EliotJ.R.R. Tolkien
PublisherWilliam Blackwood and SonsGeorge Allen & Unwin Limited
Pages880 pages (Penguin Classics edition)1178
GenreLiterary fiction · HistoricalAdventure · Fantasy

The two verdicts

Middlemarch

Middlemarch: a whole town held in one patient, forgiving gaze

Middlemarch earns its place near the top of the scale because it does something few novels attempt and almost none sustain: it gives an entire community the same depth of attention, and it makes that attention feel like a moral act rather than a technique. The writing is dense, funny and exact; the characters, from Dorothea to the least of the town's gossips, are understood rather than judged. What holds it a fraction below the very top is the cost of entry. The opening is slow, the period detail is heavy, and the narrator's habit of pausing to reflect will not suit every reader. For anyone willing to give it the first hundred pages, it repays the rest many times over, and it reads differently at every age.

Read the full review →

The Lord of the Rings

The Lord of the Rings: the template for modern fantasy remains its high-water mark

The Lord of the Rings has faults that are easy to list: a meandering opening, a narrow range of female roles and a high style that is not to all tastes. Yet the depth of its world, the moral seriousness of its themes and the emotional power of its central friendship are unrivalled. It is an all-time landmark, and it continues to justify its reputation.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.