Skip to content

Head to head

Monster vs Mushishi

Dead level: both score 9.1. What separates them is what they are for, not how good they are.

Cover of Monster
Monster

2004 · Essential

  • Johan is one of fiction's most chilling, enigmatic antagonists
  • Explores the value of life, identity and evil with philosophical depth
  • Its deliberately slow pace and long running time demand patience
Cover of Mushishi
Mushishi

2005 · Essential

  • Twenty-six self-contained tales, so any episode works as a first one
  • Background paintings that make mountains, rain and mist the true leads
  • The slow, even tempo rarely varies and can blur episodes together in a binge

Where the gap is

Sound
8.79.4
Story
9.39.0
Animation
7.89.2
Characters
9.48.6

At a glance

FactMonsterMushishi
Released7 April 200423 October 2005
StudioMadhouseArtland, Marvelous Entertainment
Episodes7426
StatusCompletedCompleted
GenreDrama · Mystery · SuspenseDrama · Fantasy · Seinen
Director—Hiroshi Nagahama

The two verdicts

Monster

Monster: a patient, chilling thriller about the cost of saving a life

Monster is a masterful psychological thriller with a legendary villain, profound themes and a remarkable sense of place. Its plain animation, occasional coincidences and slow middle stretch are real flaws. It remains one of the most acclaimed anime thrillers ever made, and a 9.1 reflects an exceptional work of television storytelling.

Read the full review →

Mushishi

Mushishi: a ghost-story anthology that treats the uncanny as natural history

Mushishi takes one idea, that the supernatural might simply be another kind of nature, and builds twenty-six quiet, careful stories from it without repeating itself or raising its voice. The art direction and Toshio Masuda's music make its rural Japan feel lived in, and the writing gives its guest characters choices that stay with the viewer long after Ginko has walked off down the road. It loses a little to the plainness of its character animation and to a tempo so even that long sittings start to drift, and its refusal to give its lead a story will frustrate some. None of that changes what it is: one of the most distinctive and assured anthology series anime has produced, and the rare show that rewards being watched slowly.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.