Skip to content

Head to head

My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy vs Nevermind

Dead level: both score 9.0. What separates them is what they are for, not how good they are.

Cover of My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy
  • Some of the most lavish, meticulously layered production in hip-hop
  • Runaway is a brave, extended piece of self-examination
  • The misogyny in several lyrics is hard to ignore
Cover of Nevermind
Nevermind

1991 · Essential

  • Kurt Cobain's gift for melody hides inside the noise on nearly every song
  • Dave Grohl's drumming is thunderous, precise and hugely influential
  • The polished mix softened the band's rawer live sound

Where the gap is

Cohesion
9.08.8
Production
9.78.6
Performance
8.89.3
Songwriting
8.99.2

At a glance

FactMy Beautiful Dark Twisted FantasyNevermind
Released22 November 201024 September 1991
ArtistKanye WestNirvana
LabelRoc-A-Fella Records, Def Jam RecordingsGeffen Records
Tracks1312
Length68:3642:38
GenreHip-hop · PopAlternative rock · Grunge

The two verdicts

My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy

My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy: maximalism as confession, ego as art

My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy scores 9.0: an exceptional album whose production, sequencing and ambition place it among the most important hip-hop records ever made. Its lyrics can be ugly as well as honest, and several songs sprawl beyond their best ideas, which keeps it below the landmark tier. But as a portrait of ego, self-loathing and grandeur rendered in sound, it has rarely been matched.

Read the full review →

Nevermind

Nevermind: Nirvana wrap punk fury in pop hooks and change rock's direction

Nevermind scores 9.0: an exceptional album whose songwriting and performances made it one of the most influential rock records ever released. Its opening run of songs is close to perfect. A slightly uneven second half and a polished sound that sometimes blunts the band's edges keep it from the very top tier, but its power remains undeniable.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.