Skip to content

Head to head

NieR: Automata vs Ōkami

Dead level: both score 9.1. What separates them is what they are for, not how good they are.

Cover of NieR: Automata
NieR: Automata

2017 · Essential

  • Later playthroughs recontextualise events rather than simply repeating them
  • Fluid PlatinumGames combat with switchable weapons and Pod support
  • The second route replays much of the first with limited variation
Cover of Ōkami
Ōkami

2006 · Essential

  • The Celestial Brush makes painting a verb, used for puzzles, fights and travel alike
  • Ink-wash art that has aged better than almost anything else from its generation
  • The opening is long, wordy and slow to hand over control

Where the gap is

Story
9.68.8
Gameplay
8.58.7
Longevity
8.88.9
Presentation
9.09.7

At a glance

FactNieR: AutomataŌkami
Released23 February 201720 April 2006
DeveloperPlatinumGamesClover Studio, Ready at Dawn
PublisherSquare EnixCapcom
PlatformsPC (Windows), PlayStation 4, Nintendo SwitchPlayStation 2, Nintendo Wii, PlayStation 3, PC (Windows)
DirectorYoko TaroHideki Kamiya
EngineCustomProprietary
GenreAction · RPG · Sci-FiAction · Adventure · Fantasy

The two verdicts

NieR: Automata

NieR: Automata uses repetition itself to ask what makes a life worth living

NieR: Automata uses its structure, music and wandering side stories to build something genuinely moving, and its thematic ambition remains rare in the medium. Repetitive early routes, a sparse world and relatively simple combat stop it short of perfection, but its story and score justify an exceptional rating.

Read the full review →

Ōkami

Ōkami: a Zelda-shaped adventure that hands you the brush and lets you repaint the world

Ōkami takes a borrowed structure and makes it new with a single idea that it never stops developing. The brush is a puzzle tool, a weapon, a way across the map and a way of saying that the world can be mended, and the art and score make every act of mending feel like an event. The score stops short of the very top because the game asks for patience twice: once at the start, through a long and talkative opening, and once at the end, through more hours than its ideas strictly need. Its combat, too, rarely asks for much. Those are honest limits on an adventure that still looks, sounds and plays like nothing else, and one that a whole generation missed the first time round.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.