Skip to content

Head to head

Nope vs The Substance

Nope takes it by 0.2, 7.8 against 7.6. The subscores below show where the gap actually is.

Cover of Nope
Nope

2022 · Good

  • Large-format photography gives the open sky real menace and scale
  • Keke Palmer and Daniel Kaluuya make a warm, funny, believable sibling pair
  • The central threads and the flashback subplot never fully knit together
Cover of The Substance
The Substance

2024 · Good

  • Demi Moore gives a raw, courageous performance of ageing and self-loathing
  • Margaret Qualley makes Sue both seductive and chillingly empty
  • Its satire is blunt and repeats the same point rather than developing it

Where the gap is

Craft
8.98.8
Story
7.17.0
Direction
8.38.3
Performances
8.08.6

At a glance

FactNopeThe Substance
Released22 July 202220 September 2024
DirectorJordan PeeleCoralie Fargeat
StarringDaniel Kaluuya, Keke Palmer, Steven YeunDemi Moore, Margaret Qualley, Dennis Quaid
Runtime130 minutes140 minutes
StudioMonkeypaw ProductionsWorking Title Films, Blacksmith
GenreSci-Fi · Mystery · HorrorSci-Fi · Drama · Horror

The two verdicts

Nope

Nope: Jordan Peele's sky-watching spectacle is ambitious, strange and uneven

Nope is a daring, visually commanding film with memorable performances and a handful of set pieces that stand with the best American genre work of recent years. Its ambition outruns its structure, however, and the Ricky Park storyline, for all its power, sits awkwardly beside the main plot. Superb craft lifts it into good-to-very-good territory, while the unevenness of its storytelling keeps it out of the top tier.

Read the full review →

The Substance

The Substance: a gleefully grotesque satire that goes for the jugular

The Substance is a daring, visually striking and brilliantly performed satire, and it was one of the most talked-about films of its year, winning the screenplay prize at Cannes. Its blunt, repetitive message and excessive final act keep it from greatness, but Demi Moore's performance and Fargeat's audacious vision make it a good and often exhilarating experience.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.