Skip to content

Head to head

Only Murders in the Building vs Wednesday

Only Murders in the Building takes it by 1.1, 8.1 against 7.0. The subscores below show where the gap actually is.

Cover of Only Murders in the Building
  • Martin, Short and Gomez have wonderfully offbeat comic chemistry
  • Clever mysteries are layered with warmth, loneliness and friendship
  • Each new season strains the premise of yet another murder
Cover of Wednesday
Wednesday

2022 · Good

  • Jenna Ortega's unblinking, deadpan Wednesday is a star-making turn
  • Emma Myers's bubbly werewolf roommate Enid is a delightful foil
  • The murder mystery follows predictable young-adult genre beats

Where the gap is

Craft
8.37.9
Story
7.66.3
Characters
8.47.2
Performances
8.98.4

At a glance

FactOnly Murders in the BuildingWednesday
Released31 August 202123 November 2022
Created bySteve Martin, John Robert HoffmanAlfred Gough, Miles Millar
StarringSteve Martin, Martin Short, Selena GomezJenna Ortega, Catherine Zeta-Jones, Luis Gómez
NetworkHuluNetflix
Seasons42
Episodes4016
GenreComedy · Crime · MysteryComedy · Fantasy · Crime

The two verdicts

Only Murders in the Building

Only Murders in the Building: a cosy whodunit with three perfectly tuned sleuths

Only Murders in the Building earns an 8.1 for its delightful central trio, witty writing and inventive production. Its increasingly strained premise, reliance on guest stars and convoluted mysteries keep it from excellence, but it remains one of television's most charming comedies.

Read the full review →

Wednesday

Wednesday: Jenna Ortega's deadpan Addams rescues a routine boarding-school mystery

Wednesday is carried by an outstanding lead performance and an appealing gothic style, with strong supporting turns and moments of genuine wit. Its predictable mystery and romantic subplots prevent it from achieving the subversive edge its heroine deserves. A 7.0 reflects a good series that is more entertaining than inventive.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.