Only Murders in the Building · 2021
Only Murders in the Building: a cosy whodunit with three perfectly tuned sleuths
Our review of Only Murders in the Building, Hulu's comedy mystery: Steve Martin, Martin Short and Selena Gomez charm, even as the formula wears.
Excellent
Editorial score out of 10
Only Murders in the Building is the television equivalent of a well-made cocktail: light, stylish and more complex than it first appears. Its premise, three mismatched neighbours start a podcast about a death in their building, pokes gentle fun at the true-crime boom, but the show's real subject is loneliness and the unexpected friendships that can cure it. That warmth, combined with the pairing of two comedy legends and a younger star, made it a hit.
- 8.1
- Editorial score
- #58
- Of 109 series reviewed
- 2021
- Released
- 4
- Seasons
After several seasons, the format shows some strain. The show remains charming, but its once-fresh concept increasingly relies on escalating guest stars and elaborate twists.
The show remains charming, but its once-fresh concept increasingly relies on escalating guest stars and elaborate twists.
Story
The first season is the strongest. The death of a young resident draws Charles, Oliver and Mabel together, each carrying their own secrets and regrets, and the mystery unfolds with playful narration, clever clues and a strong sense of emotional stakes. The show balances whodunit mechanics with meditations on ageing, grief and connection, and its twists land well.
The second season, in which the trio themselves become suspects, is fun but less focused. The third moves into theatre, following a murder during a Broadway production, and features terrific performances from Meryl Streep and Paul Rudd along with enjoyable musical numbers. The fourth sends the characters to Hollywood, where a film about their podcast is being made. The increasingly meta storylines are entertaining, but they also highlight the implausibility of so many murders around the same small circle of people.

Characters and performances
Steve Martin plays Charles with a lovely, understated melancholy, a man hiding behind the stiffness of a former television star. Martin Short is exuberant as Oliver, a showman whose theatricality masks financial desperation and a need for love. Selena Gomez, perhaps an unexpected choice, gives Mabel a deadpan wit and a quiet vulnerability that balances the older men's broader styles. The trio's generational banter is the show's greatest pleasure.
The guest cast is extensive. Tina Fey is delightfully sinister as a rival podcaster, Jane Lynch is a highlight as Charles's former stunt double, and Streep brings warmth and comic brilliance to the third season. Occasionally, however, the parade of famous faces distracts from the core characters.
Craft
The series is beautifully designed. The Arconia, with its ornate lobby, courtyard and eccentric apartments, is richly realised, and the costumes, particularly Mabel's colourful coats, became talking points. Siddhartha Khosla's jaunty score and the clever animated title sequence set a playful tone. The first season's episode told almost entirely without dialogue, from the perspective of a deaf resident, is a daring and moving highlight.
Who it is for
Only Murders in the Building is ideal for fans of cosy mysteries, character comedy and classic showbiz humour. It is light on violence and suitable for a broad audience. Viewers who prefer gritty crime drama will find it too whimsical, and those who like airtight puzzles may be frustrated by some solutions.
What works
- Martin, Short and Gomez have wonderfully offbeat comic chemistry
- Clever mysteries are layered with warmth, loneliness and friendship
- The near-silent episode The Boy from 6B is a formal triumph
- Stylish production design turns the Arconia into a character
What doesn’t
- Each new season strains the premise of yet another murder
- Guest stars sometimes overshadow the central trio
- Later mysteries rely on convoluted solutions and red herrings
Head to head
- Craft
- 8.38.2
- Story
- 7.68.2
- Characters
- 8.48.8
- Performances
- 8.99.3
Mare of Easttown edges it by 0.3. See them side by side
The verdict
Only Murders in the Building earns an 8.1 for its delightful central trio, witty writing and inventive production. Its increasingly strained premise, reliance on guest stars and convoluted mysteries keep it from excellence, but it remains one of television's most charming comedies.





