Skip to content

Head to head

Oshi no Ko vs Summer Time Rendering

Dead level: both score 8.1. What separates them is what they are for, not how good they are.

Cover of Oshi no Ko
Oshi no Ko

2023 · Excellent

  • Feature-length opening episode is a gripping, genre-shifting hook
  • Pointed critique of reality TV, online harassment and idol labour
  • Revenge thriller and showbiz procedural often pull in different directions
Cover of Summer Time Rendering
Summer Time Rendering

2022 · Excellent

  • Tight plotting that escalates stakes and rules with every loop
  • Eerie shadow doppelgängers make for genuinely creepy horror
  • Dense rules and exposition can become hard to track in later arcs

Where the gap is

Sound
8.97.8
Story
7.98.4
Animation
8.88.0
Characters
8.37.8

At a glance

FactOshi no KoSummer Time Rendering
Released12 April 202315 April 2022
StudioDoga KoboOLM
Episodes2425
StatusAiringCompleted
GenreDrama · Seinen · SuspenseSci-Fi · Mystery · Suspense
Director—Ayumu Watanabe

The two verdicts

Oshi no Ko

Oshi no Ko: a glossy idol drama with a sharp knife hidden in its sleeve

Oshi no Ko is at its best as a clear-eyed critique of an industry that consumes young performers, and its opening episode and reality TV arc are among the strongest anime drama of recent years. An uneasy balance between revenge thriller and showbiz procedural, a slower stage-play arc and some awkward handling of its premise keep it in the low eights. The divisive reception of the source manga's conclusion also adds a note of caution for viewers planning to follow the story all the way.

Read the full review →

Summer Time Rendering

Summer Time Rendering: a relentless island time-loop thriller that rarely lets up

Summer Time Rendering earns its score through consistently gripping plotting, an atmospheric setting and a lead who makes the time-loop premise feel active rather than passive. Dense later exposition, some thin supporting characters and misjudged fan service keep it from the top tier, but it is a tense, satisfying thriller that deserves a wider audience.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.