Skip to content

Head to head

Overwatch 2 vs Starfield

Starfield takes it by 0.5, 7.2 against 6.7. The subscores below show where the gap actually is.

Cover of Overwatch 2
Overwatch 2

2022 · Mixed

  • Hero kits remain inventive, readable and satisfying to master
  • The 5v5 format makes fights faster and individual impact clearer
  • Cosmetic prices and early hero unlocks behind the pass felt exploitative
Cover of Starfield
Starfield

2023 · Good

  • Faction questlines, especially the corporate espionage arc, are highly memorable
  • Deep ship builder allows creative and functional custom vessels
  • Menus and loading screens fragment exploration and break immersion

Where the gap is

Story
4.56.9
Gameplay
8.67.4
Longevity
6.88.2
Presentation
8.37.6

At a glance

FactOverwatch 2Starfield
Released4 October 20226 September 2023
DeveloperBlizzard EntertainmentBethesda Game Studios
PublisherBlizzard EntertainmentBethesda Softworks
PlatformsPC (Windows), PlayStation 5, Nintendo Switch, Xbox Series X|SPC (Windows), Xbox Series X|S
EngineCustomCreation Engine 2
GenreAction · Co-opRPG · Open world · Sci-Fi
Director—Todd Howard

The two verdicts

Overwatch 2

Overwatch 2: excellent team fights buried under a troubled free-to-play relaunch

Overwatch 2 still offers some of the most satisfying team combat in the genre, and its 5v5 format has real merits. However, aggressive monetisation, the collapse of its planned PvE ambitions and a troubled relaunch that erased the original game weigh heavily, leaving a mixed score that reflects both the brilliance of the core and the damage done around it.

Read the full review →

Starfield

Starfield: a vast Bethesda universe that too often feels far away

Starfield offers strong faction quests, satisfying combat and a superb ship builder, making it a good space RPG. However, fragmented exploration, repetitive procedural planets and a lacklustre main story prevent it from reaching the heights of Bethesda's best, earning it a good but notably flawed score.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.