Skip to content

Head to head

Pedro Páramo vs The Master and Margarita

Pedro Páramo takes it by 0.1, 9.5 against 9.4. The subscores below show where the gap actually is.

Cover of Pedro Páramo
Pedro Páramo

1955 · Masterpiece

  • Dozens of fragments, and every one of them is a scene rather than a summary
  • Rural Jalisco speech set down with no condescension towards the people speaking
  • The first pass is disorienting by design; the chronology settles on a reread
Cover of The Master and Margarita
The Master and Margarita

1966 · Essential

  • Two novels in one, Moscow farce and Jerusalem tragedy, that rhyme rather than repeat
  • Woland's retinue, above all Behemoth the cat, are among fiction's great comic creations
  • Unrevised at Bulgakov's death, and some loose threads and repetitions show

Where the gap is

Ideas
9.69.7
Story
9.28.9
Writing
9.79.4
Characters
8.99.3

At a glance

FactPedro PáramoThe Master and Margarita
Released19 March 19551966
AuthorJuan RulfoRina Sawayama, Mikhail Bulgakov
PublisherFondo de Cultura EconómicaYMCA-Press
Pages155 pages432 pages (Penguin Classics)
GenreMagical realism · Literary fictionFantasy · Literary fiction · Satire
Translator—Richard Pevear, Larissa Volokhonsky

The two verdicts

Pedro Páramo

Pedro Páramo: the short, hard novel a whole continent's fiction dates from

Almost nothing in twentieth-century fiction does this much with this little. Rulfo took the ordinary furniture of a rural novel — a father, an inheritance, a landowner, a priest — and rebuilt it out of voices with nobody standing behind them, and the technique that looks at first like difficulty turns out to be the only honest way to render a place where everyone is still talking about a past that will not close. It costs the reader something: the first pass is properly disorienting, and the women are seen largely through the men who ruined them. It remains one of the very few novels a whole continent's literature can be said to date from, and it takes an afternoon.

Read the full review →

The Master and Margarita

The Master and Margarita: the Devil's comedy that outlived the state it mocked

Few novels manage to be this funny about this much darkness. Bulgakov wrote a book he knew he would not see printed, about a city where honesty was dangerous, and filled it with a talking cat, a magic show and a Devil with impeccable manners, then set beside it the plainest and saddest retelling of Pilate's judgement in modern fiction. The structure sprawls in places, the text is not quite finished, and some of the satire needs annotation to land. None of that weighs much against the ideas, the characters and the sheer nerve of the thing. It sits just below the very top of our scale only because its rough edges are real; as a reading experience, it remains one of the essential novels of the last century.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.