Skip to content

Head to head

Preacher vs Vagabond

Vagabond takes it by 1.3, 9.1 against 7.8. The subscores below show where the gap actually is.

Cover of Preacher
Preacher

1995 · Good

  • An audacious premise that takes on religion, America and masculinity
  • Jesse, Tulip and Cassidy form a vivid, messy and loyal central trio
  • Gross-out gags and homophobic jokes have aged poorly
Cover of Vagabond
Vagabond

1998 · Essential

  • Inoue's brushwork makes faces, weather and stillness carry as much as the duels
  • Musashi changes from beast to student across the run, and the change is earned
  • The story stops mid-journey; there has been no new chapter since May 2015

Where the gap is

Art
8.29.9
Story
7.98.7
Pacing
7.07.8
Characters
8.49.3

At a glance

FactPreacherVagabond
Released1 April 19953 September 1998
WriterGarth EnnisTakehiko Inoue
ArtistGlenn Fabry, Steve DillonTakehiko Inoue
PublisherVertigoVIZ Media, Kodansha
Issues66327 chapters in 37 volumes (1998–2015); on indefinite hiatus since May 2015
GenreAction · Drama · Black comedyAction · Drama · Seinen

The two verdicts

Preacher

Preacher is a profane, blasphemous road trip with a surprisingly old-fashioned heart

Preacher is a bold, funny and genuinely affecting series, powered by three terrific central characters and a willingness to ask big questions about faith and morality. Its dated shock humour, meandering middle and conflicted view of masculinity hold it back. A 7.8 reflects a good, often brilliant series that time has not treated kindly.

Read the full review →

Vagabond

Vagabond: the best-drawn sword story in comics, and an unfinished one

Vagabond is held back from the very top of the scale by one fact no amount of craft can fix: it has no ending, and may never have one. Everything else argues for it. Inoue turned a familiar national story into a study of violence and self-knowledge, gave its hero a transformation that unfolds at the speed of a real life, and drew it with a care that makes almost any page worth stopping on. The slower later volumes ask for patience, and the violence asks for a strong stomach. What readers get in return is the most beautifully drawn sword story in comics, and a portrait of a young man learning, too slowly and at great cost, what being strong is for.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.