Skip to content

Head to head

Sherlock vs True Detective

Dead level: both score 7.8. What separates them is what they are for, not how good they are.

Cover of Sherlock
Sherlock

2010 · Good

  • Cumberbatch and Freeman form one of television's great double acts
  • Witty updates of Conan Doyle, from blogs to text messages, feel inspired
  • Later series favour twists and spectacle over coherent mysteries
Cover of True Detective
True Detective

2014 · Good

  • The first season is a mesmerising, atmospheric landmark of crime TV
  • Matthew McConaughey's philosophising Rust Cohle is unforgettable
  • The second season's convoluted plot and stilted dialogue fall flat

Where the gap is

Craft
8.38.8
Story
7.27.3
Characters
8.27.9
Performances
9.09.0

At a glance

FactSherlockTrue Detective
Released25 July 201012 January 2014
Created bySteven Moffat, Mark GatissNic Pizzolatto
StarringRupert Graves, Louise Brealey, Mark GatissMatthew McConaughey, Adria Arjona
NetworkBBC OneHBO
Seasons44
Episodes1330
GenreDrama · Crime · MysteryDrama · Crime · Mystery

The two verdicts

Sherlock

Sherlock: a thrilling modern reinvention that burned brightest in its early series

Sherlock at its peak is among the most entertaining British dramas of its era, with two lead performances that will define these characters for years to come. Its decline is real, though, and a series judged as a whole has to account for it. A 7.8 recognises brilliant early work and superb casting, weighed against later instalments that mistook cleverness for substance.

Read the full review →

True Detective

True Detective: one masterpiece season, and an anthology forever chasing it

True Detective's first season is a landmark of modern television, powered by extraordinary performances and meticulous craft. The uneven quality of subsequent seasons, however, particularly the second, means the anthology as a whole cannot sustain that level. A 7.8 reflects a series with moments of greatness weighed against notable misfires.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.