Sherlock · 2010
Sherlock: a thrilling modern reinvention that burned brightest in its early series
Sherlock review: Benedict Cumberbatch and Martin Freeman's BBC update of Conan Doyle dazzles early, before cleverness overtakes the mysteries in later series.
Good
Editorial score out of 10
When Sherlock arrived in 2010, it felt like a jolt of electricity through a well-worn genre. Mark Gatiss and Steven Moffat understood that Conan Doyle's stories were always about speed of thought, and they found a visual and verbal language to match: deductions floating on screen, a detective who texts rather than telegraphs, and a Watson who blogs about their cases. At its best, the show is fast, funny and genuinely exciting.
- 7.8
- Editorial score
- #72
- Of 109 series reviewed
- 2010
- Released
- 4
- Seasons
That best is concentrated in the first two series. As the programme became a global phenomenon, it grew more interested in its own mythology, in fan speculation and in grand emotional reversals, and the tightly plotted puzzles that made it special gave way to something more self-regarding.
The Victorian special, The Abominable Bride, is a curious experiment best appreciated by existing fans.
The cases
The early episodes are a masterclass in adaptation. A Study in Pink reworks the first Holmes novel with real wit, while A Scandal in Belgravia and The Hounds of Baskerville take familiar source material and bend it into new shapes without losing what made it work. The ninety-minute format lets the writers build layered mysteries, with red herrings and set pieces given space to land.
From the third series onwards, the balance shifts. Episodes become more concerned with the relationships between characters, which is not a flaw in itself, but the mysteries grow convoluted and resolutions increasingly rely on implausible leaps. The fourth series in particular was greeted with widespread disappointment, its final instalment reaching for operatic stakes that the show had not really set up.

Holmes and Watson
The casting is the reason Sherlock endures. Benedict Cumberbatch's Holmes is arrogant, childlike and occasionally cruel, and he delivers dense torrents of deduction with astonishing clarity. Martin Freeman is equally important: his Watson is no bumbling sidekick but a capable, prickly man with his own damage, and his exasperated reactions ground the show's more fanciful flights.
The supporting cast is strong throughout. Una Stubbs brings warmth and mischief to Mrs Hudson, Rupert Graves is a likeable Lestrade, and Gatiss plays Mycroft with icy relish. Andrew Scott's Moriarty is a deliberately divisive interpretation, more pop-star psychopath than criminal professor, and his early scenes crackle.
Style and craft
Paul McGuigan's direction on several key episodes set the template: kinetic editing, inventive on-screen graphics and a London that looks both glossy and slightly unreal. The score by David Arnold and Michael Price is propulsive and instantly recognisable. Even when the writing falters, the production rarely looks anything less than handsome.
Who it is for
Newcomers should treat the first two series as essential and the third as enjoyable if uneven. The Victorian special, The Abominable Bride, is a curious experiment best appreciated by existing fans. The fourth series is for completists who want to see how the story concludes.
What works
- Cumberbatch and Freeman form one of television's great double acts
- Witty updates of Conan Doyle, from blogs to text messages, feel inspired
- Feature-length episodes give each case room to breathe
- Andrew Scott's Moriarty is a gleefully unhinged adversary
What doesn’t
- Later series favour twists and spectacle over coherent mysteries
- The fourth series strains credibility and was widely seen as a misstep
- Long gaps between short runs make it feel fragmented as a whole
Head to head
- Craft
- 8.37.3
- Story
- 7.26.8
- Characters
- 8.27.4
- Performances
- 9.08.4
Sherlock edges it by 0.5. See them side by side
The verdict
Sherlock at its peak is among the most entertaining British dramas of its era, with two lead performances that will define these characters for years to come. Its decline is real, though, and a series judged as a whole has to account for it. A 7.8 recognises brilliant early work and superb casting, weighed against later instalments that mistook cleverness for substance.





