Skip to content

Head to head

Dexter vs Sherlock

Sherlock takes it by 0.5, 7.8 against 7.3. The subscores below show where the gap actually is.

Cover of Dexter
Dexter

2006 · Good

  • Michael C. Hall makes a killer's inner monologue darkly compelling
  • The fourth season, with John Lithgow, is gripping antihero drama
  • Later seasons repeat the villain-of-the-year formula with diminishing returns
Cover of Sherlock
Sherlock

2010 · Good

  • Cumberbatch and Freeman form one of television's great double acts
  • Witty updates of Conan Doyle, from blogs to text messages, feel inspired
  • Later series favour twists and spectacle over coherent mysteries

Where the gap is

Craft
7.38.3
Story
6.87.2
Characters
7.48.2
Performances
8.49.0

At a glance

FactDexterSherlock
Released1 October 200625 July 2010
Created byJames Manos JrSteven Moffat, Mark Gatiss
StarringMichael C. Hall, Jennifer Carpenter, David ZayasRupert Graves, Louise Brealey, Mark Gatiss
NetworkShowtimeBBC One
Seasons84
Episodes9613
GenreDrama · Crime · MysteryDrama · Crime · Mystery

The two verdicts

Dexter

Dexter: a thrilling antihero study that squandered its best years

Dexter scores 7.3 as a whole: its best seasons deserve considerably more, thanks to Hall's defining performance and some excellent plotting, but the steep decline in its second half and a notoriously weak finale drag the complete series down. It remains an influential, often thrilling show that is best remembered selectively.

Read the full review →

Sherlock

Sherlock: a thrilling modern reinvention that burned brightest in its early series

Sherlock at its peak is among the most entertaining British dramas of its era, with two lead performances that will define these characters for years to come. Its decline is real, though, and a series judged as a whole has to account for it. A 7.8 recognises brilliant early work and superb casting, weighed against later instalments that mistook cleverness for substance.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.