Skip to content

Head to head

Sinners vs The Dark Knight

Dead level: both score 9.2. What separates them is what they are for, not how good they are.

Cover of Sinners
Sinners

2025 · Essential

  • A first hour that builds a whole town before it needs a monster
  • Michael B. Jordan plays the twins as two different kinds of tired
  • The turn into horror leaves several of the joint's best characters behind
Cover of The Dark Knight
The Dark Knight

2008 · Essential

  • Heath Ledger's Joker is a truly unpredictable, mesmerising screen villain
  • Aaron Eckhart's Harvey Dent gives the story a tragic moral centre
  • The overstuffed final act piles on too many climaxes and speeches

Where the gap is

Craft
9.69.3
Story
8.89.0
Direction
9.49.2
Performances
9.39.5

At a glance

FactSinnersThe Dark Knight
Released18 April 202518 July 2008
DirectorRyan CooglerChristopher Nolan
StarringMichael B. Jordan, Miles Caton, Hailee SteinfeldChristian Bale, Michael Caine, Heath Ledger
Runtime137 minutes152 minutes
StudioProximity MediaLegendary Entertainment, Warner Bros. Entertainment
GenreDrama · Thriller · HistoricalAction · Drama · Superhero

The two verdicts

Sinners

Sinners: the studio horror that bet everything on the blues

Sinners is a big studio film that behaves like a personal one, and the combination is rare enough to be worth celebrating even when the last act strains. Coogler builds a place, populates it with people whose debts and loyalties are clear, and only then lets the horror in — so the second half has stakes that most genre films have to fake. Jordan is superb in both halves of his double role, Arkapaw's 65mm images are the best-looking of the year by some distance, and the music is not decoration but the argument itself. The reservations are real: the plotting frays under pressure and a few characters deserve more than the ending has room for. It remains the most confident American horror film in years.

Read the full review →

The Dark Knight

The Dark Knight: the superhero film that became a sprawling crime epic

The Dark Knight is an exceptional blockbuster that changed expectations of what the genre could achieve. Its gripping story, superb craft and an iconic villain performance make it essential. An overstuffed finale, some clumsy dialogue and underwritten characters keep it just short of landmark status, but it remains one of the most accomplished and influential superhero films ever made.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.