Skip to content

Head to head

Stardew Valley vs Super Smash Bros. Ultimate

Dead level: both score 9.1. What separates them is what they are for, not how good they are.

Cover of Stardew Valley
Stardew Valley

2016 · Essential

  • A wonderfully balanced loop of farming, fishing, mining and socialising
  • Pelican Town's residents have surprisingly thoughtful personal stories
  • Early energy limits and slow tools make the first days sluggish
Cover of Super Smash Bros. Ultimate
  • An unprecedented roster spanning decades of Nintendo and third-party history
  • Faster, tighter fighting than the previous entry, accessible yet deep
  • Online play suffers from lag and inconsistent matchmaking

Where the gap is

Story
8.06.0
Gameplay
9.29.3
Longevity
9.79.6
Presentation
8.49.4

At a glance

FactStardew ValleySuper Smash Bros. Ultimate
Released26 February 20167 December 2018
DeveloperConcernedApeSora, Bandai Namco Studios
PublisherChucklefish, ConcernedApeNintendo
PlatformsPC (Windows), Nintendo Switch, PlayStation 4, Xbox OneNintendo Switch
DirectorEric BaroneMasahiro Sakurai
EngineMonoGameCustom
GenreRPG · IndieAction

The two verdicts

Stardew Valley

Stardew Valley is a gentle farming life sim with a remarkably big heart

Stardew Valley combines farming, exploration and social storytelling into a rich, rewarding and consistently charming experience that has only grown over time. A sluggish opening, fussy fishing and basic combat are the only real blemishes. Beyond them lies one of the most generous, humane games of its kind, still expanding years after release and still setting the standard for the farming life sim.

Read the full review →

Super Smash Bros. Ultimate

Super Smash Bros. Ultimate is a museum of gaming that also plays brilliantly

Super Smash Bros. Ultimate is a generous, fast and finely tuned crossover fighter whose roster, stages and music make it a lasting celebration of the medium. Unreliable online play, a padded adventure mode and a slow unlocking process are its clearest failings, but they barely dent one of the finest party fighters ever made.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.