Skip to content

Head to head

The Holdovers vs The Wild Robot

Dead level: both score 8.3. What separates them is what they are for, not how good they are.

Cover of The Holdovers
The Holdovers

2023 · Excellent

  • Paul Giamatti turns a pedantic misanthrope into a wonderfully rich character
  • Da'Vine Joy Randolph's grief-stricken Mary is quietly devastating
  • The story's arc of prickly people softening is familiar and predictable
Cover of The Wild Robot
The Wild Robot

2024 · Excellent

  • Lush, painterly animation gives the island the look of a living storybook
  • Lupita Nyong'o finds warmth and humour in Roz's evolving personality
  • The action-heavy final act feels more conventional than what precedes it

Where the gap is

Craft
8.59.2
Story
8.08.1
Direction
8.38.6
Performances
9.28.4

At a glance

FactThe HoldoversThe Wild Robot
Released27 October 202327 September 2024
DirectorAlexander PayneChris Sanders
StarringPaul Giamatti, Da'Vine Joy Randolph, Carrie Preston—
Runtime133 minutes101 minutes
StudioMiramaxDreamWorks Animation
GenreDrama · ComedyAdventure · Animation · Family

The two verdicts

The Holdovers

The Holdovers: a gruff, gentle Christmas film that earns its warmth

The Holdovers is a warm, witty and beautifully acted film that brings depth and honesty to a familiar formula, and it was widely embraced by critics and audiences. Its predictable arc, occasional sentimentality and slow patches keep it from greatness, but its three central performances make it an excellent and moving experience that is likely to become a seasonal favourite.

Read the full review →

The Wild Robot

The Wild Robot: a painterly, heart-tugging tale of nature and nurture

The Wild Robot is a gorgeous, funny and moving animated film with superb voice performances and a heartfelt story. Its conventional, action-heavy final act and occasionally insistent emotional cues prevent it from reaching the very top tier, but it remains one of the best animated films of its year and a new family favourite.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.