Skip to content

Head to head

The Witcher vs True Detective: Night Country

True Detective: Night Country takes it by 0.1, 6.6 against 6.5. The subscores below show where the gap actually is.

Cover of The Witcher
The Witcher

2019 · Mixed

  • Henry Cavill's gruff, dryly funny Geralt honours the books' hero
  • Monster-hunting episodes capture the source's grim fairy-tale spirit
  • The first season's jumbled timelines confuse more than they intrigue
Cover of True Detective: Night Country
  • Jodie Foster brings bristling, sardonic authority to Liz Danvers
  • The perpetual Alaskan darkness creates a genuinely eerie atmosphere
  • The mystery's resolution feels thin after an intriguing build-up

Where the gap is

Craft
6.68.4
Story
6.05.8
Characters
6.86.8
Performances
7.28.2

At a glance

FactThe WitcherTrue Detective: Night Country
Released20 December 201914 January 2024
Created byLauren Schmidt HissrichIssa López
StarringHenry Cavill, Freya Allan, Anya ChalotraJodie Foster, Kali Reis
NetworkNetflixHBO
Seasons31
Episodes246
GenreAction · Drama · FantasyDrama · Crime · Mystery

The two verdicts

The Witcher

The Witcher: Henry Cavill's monster hunter deserved a sharper, steadier series

The Witcher has a strong lead performance, engaging monster-hunting episodes and moments of genuine fantasy spectacle. Its confusing narratives, uneven production and loss of focus across seasons prevent it from becoming a genre great. A 6.5 reflects a mixed series that never fully capitalised on its considerable potential.

Read the full review →

True Detective: Night Country

True Detective: Night Country turns the anthology into an icy, divisive ghost story

True Detective: Night Country is a bold, atmospheric reinvention powered by strong performances and memorable imagery. Its underdeveloped supernatural threads and polarising resolution undercut its promise. A 6.6 reflects a mixed season with significant strengths that ultimately fails to deliver a fully satisfying mystery.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.