Skip to content

Head to head

True Detective vs Twin Peaks

Twin Peaks takes it by 1.1, 8.9 against 7.8. The subscores below show where the gap actually is.

Cover of True Detective
True Detective

2014 · Good

  • The first season is a mesmerising, atmospheric landmark of crime TV
  • Matthew McConaughey's philosophising Rust Cohle is unforgettable
  • The second season's convoluted plot and stilted dialogue fall flat
Cover of Twin Peaks
Twin Peaks

1990 · Excellent

  • A pilot that treats grief as seriously as it treats the crime
  • Dale Cooper, a detective whose method is equal parts forensics, coffee and dreams
  • The second season sags badly once the central question is answered

Where the gap is

Craft
8.89.6
Story
7.38.1
Characters
7.99.3
Performances
9.09.0

At a glance

FactTrue DetectiveTwin Peaks
Released12 January 20148 April 1990
Created byNic PizzolattoMark Frost, David Lynch
StarringMatthew McConaughey, Adria ArjonaKyle MacLachlan, Michael Ontkean, Sheryl Lee
NetworkHBOABC
Seasons42 (1990–1991); continued in the 2017 revival, Twin Peaks: The Return
Episodes3030
GenreDrama · Crime · MysteryDrama · Crime · Mystery

The two verdicts

True Detective

True Detective: one masterpiece season, and an anthology forever chasing it

True Detective's first season is a landmark of modern television, powered by extraordinary performances and meticulous craft. The uneven quality of subsequent seasons, however, particularly the second, means the anthology as a whole cannot sustain that level. A 7.8 reflects a series with moments of greatness weighed against notable misfires.

Read the full review →

Twin Peaks

Twin Peaks: the murder mystery that taught network television to dream, then lost its way

Twin Peaks earns its place by what its first season and a half achieved: a network murder mystery that took grief, desire and fear seriously, wrapped them in comedy and fog, and looked and sounded like nothing else on television. Dale Cooper and the town around him remain some of the most vivid creations the medium has produced, and the craft, from Badalamenti's score to the woods, has not dated. The score stops short of the top tier because the second season, robbed of its engine, spends too long looking for a new one, and because the tonal swings that make the best hours unforgettable make the worst ones hard to sit through. Watch it whole, forgive the middle, and stay for the ending.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.