Skip to content
Series reviewExcellent

Twin Peaks · 1990

Twin Peaks: the murder mystery that taught network television to dream, then lost its way

Twin Peaks review. Mark Frost and David Lynch's 1990 ABC series is a soap, a procedural and a nightmare at once, with a second season that wanders badly.

Voxizer EditorialSection editor Ignacio Pineda9 min read

Excellent

Editorial score out of 10

Twin Peaks opens with a woman's body wrapped in plastic and a father who cannot stop screaming, and within an hour it has also found room for a man in a dark suit rhapsodising about the coffee. That combination, grief played absolutely straight beside comedy played almost as straight, is the whole show in miniature. Mark Frost and David Lynch made a murder mystery for ABC in 1990 and smuggled inside it a soap opera, a small-town satire and a horror story about what families hide, and for one astonishing season the four never trip over each other.

8.9
Editorial score
#18
Of 109 series reviewed
1990
Released
30
Episodes

The second season is another matter. Pushed to solve its central crime early, the show spends much of its remaining run looking for a reason to exist, finds a few, and loses a lot of its audience on the way. We think the original run is still essential television, but it is essential the way a great unfinished building is: you visit for what stands, and you accept the scaffolding.

The premise

The town of Twin Peaks sits in the forests of Washington State, close to the Canadian border, and runs on lumber, pie and secrets. When a logger finds Laura Palmer's body on the riverbank, the news moves through the town in a single long morning: the school, the diner, the sawmill, the hotel owned by the richest man in the county. The pilot's cleverest decision is to let the audience meet everyone through the shock of that one death, so that each character is introduced by the way they take the news.

Then Agent Cooper drives in, dictating notes into a tape recorder for a colleague called Diane who is never seen. He is courteous, precise and delighted by almost everything, and he solves problems through a mix of procedure and intuition that gets stranger as the first season goes on. By the third episode he is acting on a dream, and the show has made clear that the dream is to be taken seriously. Laura herself, glimpsed in home videos and a framed homecoming portrait, becomes more present the more the town learns about her.

She's dead. Wrapped in plastic.

— Pete Martell, in the pilot

That line, delivered flatly over the phone to the sheriff, became the show's calling card, and it captures how the series works. The horror is in the plainness. Nobody in Twin Peaks speaks in a heightened register about the worst thing that has ever happened to them, and that restraint makes the moments when they break, as Ray Wise's Leland Palmer does again and again, almost unbearable to watch.

Twin Peaks
Twin PeaksLynch/Frost Productions, via TVmaze

Two seasons, two shows

The first season was eight episodes, including a pilot that runs to feature length, and it plays like one long, carefully paced film. Lynch directed the pilot and the following episode before leaving to finish Wild at Heart; Frost and a small group of writers and directors kept the tone remarkably consistent in his absence. Each episode covers roughly a day, which slows the clock and lets small things, a cigarette, a song on a jukebox, a phone call, carry weight.

The original run
SeasonAiredEpisodesIn one line
OneApril–May 19908A near-flawless slow burn, pilot included
TwoSept 1990–June 199122A strong opening run, a long drift, a ferocious finale
Related1992 and 2017Film and revivalFire Walk with Me and The Return extend the story

The second season had twenty-two episodes and a network that wanted answers. Lynch has said he never meant to reveal who killed Laura Palmer, and that resolving it so early killed the goose that laid the golden egg. Once the question is settled, midway through the season, the show hands its time to subplots that range from charming to aimless. ABC moved it around the schedule and then off it for weeks in early 1991, and a fan letter-writing campaign could only win it a short reprieve. The last two episodes aired back to back on 10 June 1991.

Watch
Twin Peaks — trailer

Characters

What keeps Twin Peaks watchable even at its weakest is the town. There are more than twenty regulars, and the show trusts each one to carry a scene: the Log Lady, who carries a log and speaks for it; the deputy who weeps at crime scenes; the receptionist whose phone transfers are a small comedy routine; the diner owner trapped in a marriage to a man fresh out of prison. These are soap-opera types, and the series knows it, but the writing gives each of them an inner life that the plot keeps finding uses for.

How it measures up

Atmosphere
10/10
Fog, firs and fluorescent light; nothing else on network television looked like it
Mystery momentum
8/10
Relentless for the first season and a half, then gone
Comedy
7/10
Deadpan and frequent; some running jokes outstay their welcome
Horror
8/10
Rare but properly frightening when it arrives
Consistency
5/10
The gap between the best and the weakest hours is wide

Cooper is the key to all of it. He enters as the outsider who will explain the town to us, and instead he falls in love with it: the Douglas firs, the cherry pie, the honesty of Sheriff Truman. Because he takes the town at face value, the audience does too, and that makes the rot underneath more shocking when it shows. Audrey Horne, a teenager with her own ideas about how to help the investigation, is the other character who gives the first season its spark; Sherilyn Fenn plays her as a girl testing how much power she has, and the show is wise enough to let the answer be complicated.

Gallery · 3 imagesLynch/Frost Productions, frame from the MUBI teaser

Performances

Kyle MacLachlan had worked with Lynch on Dune and Blue Velvet, and here he finds a register nobody else could have found: sincere to the point of comedy, but never winking. Michael Ontkean, as Truman, is the straight man the series needs, a decent, solid sheriff whose quiet reactions let Cooper be as odd as he likes. Their friendship is the warmest thing in a cold story, and the show leans on it more as the plot weakens.

Sheryl Lee was cast, by Lynch's own account, largely to play a body, and turned the role into the spine of the series and, later, of the film. Ray Wise has the hardest job in the cast, a father whose grief arrives in waves that bend the scenes around him, and he plays it without fear of looking ridiculous. Piper Laurie, Joan Chen, Jack Nance and Catherine E. Coulson fill out an ensemble that rarely puts a foot wrong, even when the writing does.

Craft

Twin Peaks is often credited with showing that network television could look like cinema, and the claim holds up. The pilot was shot on location around Snoqualmie and North Bend in Washington, and the series builds a geography from a few recurring images: the falls, the sawmill blades, the traffic light swinging over an empty road at night. Interiors are panelled in wood, lit warm, and then interrupted by fluorescent tubes that flicker when something is wrong.

  1. 1986

    Lynch's Blue Velvet sets out the small-town darkness the series will explore

  2. 1989

    The pilot is shot in Washington State for ABC

  3. 8 April 1990

    Twin Peaks premieres on ABC

  4. January 1991

    Wins the Golden Globe for best television drama

  5. 10 June 1991

    The final two episodes air back to back

  6. 1992

    The prequel film Fire Walk with Me is released

  7. 2017

    Twin Peaks: The Return revives the series on Showtime

Angelo Badalamenti's music does as much as any actor. The theme, a slow synthesiser line over a twanging bass, plays like a lullaby and a warning at once, and Laura Palmer's theme swells from tenderness into dread in a single phrase. The songs Badalamenti wrote with Lynch for Julee Cruise drift through the Roadhouse scenes like smoke. The sound design, the hum of electricity, the wind in the trees, works on the nerves long after the dialogue has stopped.

Where to start

Start at the pilot and watch in order; the series is unusually cumulative, and the early episodes repay close attention. If the second season starts to lose you, push on: the final episode, directed by Lynch, is as strange and frightening as anything in the first, and it sets up everything that followed. The obvious comparison in the catalogue is True Detective, which inherited the show's fascination with rot behind a pastoral surface, and Lost, which inherited its mystery-box structure along with its habit of promising more than it could deliver.

Head to head

Craft
9.68.8
Story
8.17.3
Characters
9.37.9
Performances
9.09.0

Twin Peaks edges it by 1.1. See them side by side

For players, the line runs straight to Remedy's Alan Wake 2, which wears its debt to the town, the diner and the dreaming detective openly. Twin Peaks is the source, and it remains stranger than its descendants.

For you if

  • Anyone curious about where modern prestige television's mood and mystery came from
  • Viewers who enjoy a town full of eccentrics as much as the case itself
  • Fans of David Lynch's films who want them stretched across thirty hours

Not for you if

  • Viewers who need a mystery to resolve neatly and stay resolved
  • Anyone with little patience for camp sitting next to genuine horror
  • Those who dislike slow television; the drift in season two is real

Both seasons are available to stream in the UK, and the official page is the right place to begin.

What works

  • A pilot that treats grief as seriously as it treats the crime
  • Dale Cooper, a detective whose method is equal parts forensics, coffee and dreams
  • Badalamenti's score sets the mood before a single line is spoken
  • Soap, procedural, comedy and horror share every hour without cancelling out

What doesn’t

  • The second season sags badly once the central question is answered
  • Several subplots run for weeks on the strength of a single joke
  • Its tone swings so hard that some scenes read as parody of the show itself
ExcellentHow we score

The verdict

Twin Peaks earns its place by what its first season and a half achieved: a network murder mystery that took grief, desire and fear seriously, wrapped them in comedy and fog, and looked and sounded like nothing else on television. Dale Cooper and the town around him remain some of the most vivid creations the medium has produced, and the craft, from Badalamenti's score to the woods, has not dated. The score stops short of the top tier because the second season, robbed of its engine, spends too long looking for a new one, and because the tonal swings that make the best hours unforgettable make the worst ones hard to sit through. Watch it whole, forgive the middle, and stay for the ending.

Quick answers

Is Twin Peaks worth watching?

Voxizer scores Twin Peaks (1990) 8.9 out of 10 — excellent. Twin Peaks earns its place by what its first season and a half achieved: a network murder mystery that took grief, desire and fear seriously, wrapped them in comedy and fog, and looked and sounded like nothing else on television. Dale Cooper and the town around him remain some of the most vivid creations the medium has produced, and the craft, from Badalamenti's score to the woods, has not dated.

Who will enjoy Twin Peaks?

Anyone curious about where modern prestige television's mood and mystery came from. Viewers who enjoy a town full of eccentrics as much as the case itself. Fans of David Lynch's films who want them stretched across thirty hours.

Who should skip Twin Peaks?

Viewers who need a mystery to resolve neatly and stay resolved. Anyone with little patience for camp sitting next to genuine horror. Those who dislike slow television; the drift in season two is real.

What is Twin Peaks like, in short?

The first season is among the most influential hours American television has produced. Kyle MacLachlan's Dale Cooper is the warm, odd centre that makes the strangeness approachable. Lynch and Badalamenti give a network drama the texture of a film, from the pines to the diner booths. The middle of season two drifts; patience is rewarded by a finale that recovers its nerve.

What readers say

Written by Voxizer members and checked by our moderators before they appear.

Written reviews

–

No written reviews yet

Write a review
9–10
0
7–8.5
0
5–6.5
0
3–4.5
0
0–2.5
0

Nobody has reviewed Twin Peaks yet. Be the first.

All reviews →

Verified sources

Published by the Voxizer editorial team — David Abellán, Ignacio Pineda, Pablo Huguet. Section editor for series: Ignacio Pineda.

Revision history

  1. Published

Scores are revised when the facts behind them change, and the change is recorded here. How we score.