BioShock Infinite · 2013
BioShock Infinite soars as a setting and stumbles when it reaches for the gun
BioShock Infinite review: Irrational's floating city of Columbia is a stunning, thought-provoking setting, but its violent combat sits uneasily beside it.
Excellent
Editorial score out of 10
BioShock Infinite opens with one of the great arrivals in games: a lighthouse, a rocket and a first glimpse of Columbia, a city of gold-leaf buildings and patriotic statues drifting through the clouds. For its first hour it is a mesmerising piece of world-building, a sunlit utopia whose menace becomes clear gradually and deliberately.
- 8.5
- Editorial score
- #83
- Of 116 games reviewed
- 2013
- Released
- 9.4
- Best at: Presentation
What follows is a very good shooter with an ambitious story, but also a game in constant tension with itself. The ideas are large and the setting is exceptional; the moment-to-moment violence is louder and more conventional than either deserves.
She never needs protecting, tosses Booker ammunition and health when supplies run low, and can open Tears to bring in cover, turrets or other useful objects.
How it plays
Booker carries two firearms at a time and a set of Vigors, which function much like the Plasmids of earlier BioShock games: possessing machines, launching crows, electrocuting groups. Combining Vigors with weapons gives encounters some tactical colour, and gear pieces add passive bonuses.
The standout mechanic is the Sky-Line, a network of rails that Booker can ride using his skyhook. Leaping between rails, dropping onto enemies and swinging around arenas gives larger fights a pleasing sense of speed. Elizabeth is also well designed as a companion. She never needs protecting, tosses Booker ammunition and health when supplies run low, and can open Tears to bring in cover, turrets or other useful objects.
The weakness is quantity and repetition. The campaign is dominated by firefights against a limited range of enemies, and the two-weapon limit discourages experimentation. After a while, combat stops feeling like a response to the world and starts feeling like a toll to pass through it.

World and story
Columbia is a triumph of design. Its propaganda posters, carnival games, religious imagery and ideology of racial and national purity make for an unsettling satire, and its contrasts between polished public spaces and exploited labour are pointed. Voxophone recordings and environmental details deepen the history for players who look.
The relationship between Booker and Elizabeth anchors the story, and the performances by Troy Baker and Courtnee Draper give it genuine warmth. The narrative takes big swings with themes of choice, identity and alternate realities, and its later stretches became among the most debated in the medium. Its handling of racism and the uprising against Columbia's ruling class, however, drew substantial criticism for flattening real injustice into a both-sides spectacle.
Presentation
Art direction carries Infinite well beyond the technical limits of its engine and generation. The palette of bright skies, brass and bunting remains striking, and the city's architecture feels coherent and lived in. Music is used cleverly, including anachronistic period-style covers of later pop songs that hint at deeper mysteries. The later areas grow darker and less distinctive, but the overall aesthetic has aged gracefully.
Who it is for
This suits players who value narrative and setting and do not mind a heavy layer of shooting to get to them. Fans of the original BioShock will recognise the structure and themes, though Infinite trades claustrophobia for open skies. Those looking for immersive-sim freedom may find it more linear than its heritage suggests. The Burial at Sea expansions offer a worthwhile coda.
What works
- Columbia is one of the most memorable settings in shooter history
- Elizabeth is a helpful, expressive companion rather than a burden
- Sky-Line rail combat adds speed and verticality to firefights
- A bold, discussion-provoking narrative that rewards attention
What doesn’t
- Relentless combat feels at odds with the game's thoughtful themes
- Its treatment of racism and revolution was criticised as simplistic
- Two-weapon limit and a thin enemy variety flatten the shooting
Head to head
- Story
- 8.89.5
- Gameplay
- 7.68.6
- Longevity
- 7.28.9
- Presentation
- 9.48.8
Mass Effect 2 edges it by 0.7. See them side by side
The verdict
BioShock Infinite earns an excellent score for its unforgettable setting, strong central relationship and bold storytelling. Its repetitive, often gratuitous combat and a muddled approach to its most serious themes keep it from greatness, but few shooters have ever been as ambitious or as visually memorable.





