Bone · 1991
Bone begins as a cartoon romp and grows into a genuine fantasy epic
Bone is Jeff Smith's self-published epic, blending Pogo-style slapstick with a sweeping fantasy war, and it remains one of comics' great all-ages reads.
Essential
Editorial score out of 10
Bone is one of those rare works that seems to belong to everyone. It opens with three cartoon critters wandering through a desert, looking like refugees from a Sunday newspaper strip, and ends as a sprawling fantasy about war, destiny and grief. That Jeff Smith pulls off the transition at all is remarkable; that he does it while self-publishing more than a decade of monthly issues is close to heroic.
- 9.2
- Editorial score
- #7
- Of 53 comics reviewed
- 1991
- Released
- 55
- Issues
The comparison most often made is Pogo meets The Lord of the Rings, and it is apt. The brilliance is that the two halves do not undercut each other. The jokes make the danger land harder, and the danger makes the jokes feel earned.
His sense of pacing within a page is superb, with silent panels used for both punchlines and dread.
A valley full of trouble
The story starts small. Phoney Bone has been chased out of Boneville after one scheme too many, with his amiable cousins in tow, and the three become separated in an unfamiliar valley. Fone Bone, the earnest everyman with a Moby Dick obsession, finds his way to Thorn and Gran'ma Ben, who races cows and fights rat creatures with her bare hands. Early chapters are gentle and very funny, from Smiley Bone's cheerful idiocy to the quarrelling rat creatures debating recipes for quiche.
By the midpoint, the valley's history comes into focus: a fallen kingdom, a hooded enemy, dreams that carry meaning and a young woman with a hidden inheritance. Smith lets the scale widen gradually, so the shift never feels like a bait and switch.

Smith's cartooning
The art is exceptional. Smith draws the Bones in a rubbery, classic animation style, all expressive eyes and perfect comic timing, while the humans, forests and mountains are rendered with a fine, detailed brush. That contrast becomes a storytelling tool: the cartoon cousins look like visitors in someone else's grand legend, which is exactly what they are.
His sense of pacing within a page is superb, with silent panels used for both punchlines and dread. The original black-and-white pages have enormous clarity, and the later colour editions by Steve Hamaker make the book especially welcoming for younger readers.
When the epic takes over
The final third is where opinions split. As the war intensifies and the prophecy mechanics come to the fore, the book becomes more solemn and exposition-heavy. Phoney and Smiley, so central to the early humour, drift to the edges of the story, and some readers miss the looser, episodic charm of the first volumes. The mythology is coherent but occasionally explained more than dramatised.
Even so, the characters carry it. Thorn's growth from farm girl to reluctant leader is handled with real sensitivity, and Fone Bone's decency gives the story a warm heart right to the end.
Who it is for
Bone is an ideal first long-form comic for children of around nine and up, and it is equally rewarding for adults who grew up on fantasy novels or classic animation. It is one of the most frequently recommended gateways into the medium for good reason.
What works
- Jeff Smith's cartooning blends Walt Kelly slapstick with lush fantasy landscapes
- Phoney Bone's greed and the stupid, stupid rat creatures are consistently funny
- Thorn and Gran'ma Ben are memorable, capable heroines
- Works for children and adults without talking down to either
What doesn’t
- Later chapters get heavy with prophecy and lose some comic sparkle
- The Bone cousins can feel sidelined once the mythic plot takes over
- The tonal shift from gag strip to war epic will not suit every reader
Head to head
- Art
- 9.59.5
- Story
- 9.09.7
- Pacing
- 8.48.3
- Characters
- 9.49.4
Nausicaä of the Valley of the Wind edges it by 0.1. See them side by side
The verdict
Bone is a landmark of independent comics: beautifully drawn, genuinely funny and ambitious enough to become a real epic. Its later chapters are heavier and slower, and the comic cousins lose some of their spotlight, which keeps it just short of a perfect score. A 9.2 reflects an exceptional work that has earned its place on every shelf.




