Diablo IV · 2023
Diablo IV nails its gothic mood but struggled to build an endgame worth staying for
Diablo IV review: Blizzard's dark action RPG returns with a superb gothic atmosphere and strong campaign, but its live service endgame has been uneven.
Good
Editorial score out of 10
Diablo IV began on strong footing. Its campaign, atmosphere and art direction offered a welcome return to the gothic darkness that fans had long wanted, a sharp contrast with the brighter tone of Diablo III. Lilith is one of the series' most memorable villains, and Sanctuary has rarely looked so grim or so detailed.
- 7.5
- Editorial score
- #112
- Of 116 games reviewed
- 2023
- Released
- 8.9
- Best at: Presentation
The difficulty came after the credits. As a live service game built around seasons and long-term loot chasing, Diablo IV spent much of its first year reworking systems that had been widely criticised. It is a better game now than at launch, but its identity as a long-term hobby remains uneven.
Cinematics are superb, with a series of dark, dramatic set pieces, and side quests explore the struggles of ordinary people in Sanctuary.
How it plays
Combat is responsive and weighty. Each class offers a distinct feel: Barbarians swap between weapons, Necromancers command armies of the dead, Druids shapeshift and summon storms, Rogues combine traps and speed, and Sorcerers control elemental magic. Skill trees and legendary item powers allow a good degree of experimentation.
The open world includes world bosses, strongholds that transform areas once cleared, and events that attract other players. Dungeons are plentiful, though many share layouts and objectives.
At launch, the loot system was a major problem. Items were cluttered with minor bonuses, and level scaling meant progress often felt invisible. Subsequent seasonal updates overhauled itemisation, simplified stats and added more rewarding endgame activities, significantly improving the experience. Even so, some seasons have been more engaging than others.

World and story
The campaign is one of the strongest in the series. It follows a wanderer drawn into a struggle between Lilith and those who oppose her, including the fallen angel Inarius. Cinematics are superb, with a series of dark, dramatic set pieces, and side quests explore the struggles of ordinary people in Sanctuary.
The regions, from snowy mountains and misty highlands to arid steppes and swamps, are atmospheric and detailed. The Vessel of Hatred expansion added a new jungle region and class, continuing the story, though opinions about its narrative conclusion were mixed.
Presentation
Diablo IV's art direction is its greatest strength. Muted colours, ruined towns and grotesque monsters recall Diablo II, and the level of detail in environments and animations is impressive. The music and sound effects create a heavy, oppressive mood that suits the game perfectly. Blizzard's pre-rendered cinematics are among the best in the industry.
The live service layer is less successful. A premium currency shop sells cosmetics at prices many players considered high, seasonal battle passes add further monetisation, and an internet connection is required at all times, even when playing alone.
Who it is for
This is for fans of dark fantasy and action RPGs who enjoy a strong campaign and an atmospheric world. Players who like seasonal resets and experimenting with builds will find plenty to engage with. Those who prefer a complete, offline experience or dislike ongoing monetisation may find the structure frustrating. Players who left early on may find the current version significantly improved.
What works
- Grim, gothic atmosphere that recaptures the spirit of Diablo II
- Lilith is a compelling antagonist in a well-staged campaign
- Class skill trees support satisfying and distinct builds
- Detailed open world with memorable regions and dungeons
What doesn’t
- Endgame loot and progression were widely criticised as flat at launch
- Seasonal structure and a pricey cosmetic shop feel heavy-handed
- Always-online requirement with no offline option even for solo play
Head to head
- Story
- 7.98.1
- Gameplay
- 7.87.7
- Longevity
- 6.86.9
- Presentation
- 8.98.9
Final Fantasy XVI edges it by 0.4. See them side by side
The verdict
As a campaign and a piece of world-building, Diablo IV is excellent, and its presentation is among the finest in the genre. As a long-term loot game, it launched with serious weaknesses and has spent considerable effort correcting them, while monetisation and online requirements remain sore points. The score reflects a good game whose parts do not always pull in the same direction.





