Final Fantasy XVI · 2023
Final Fantasy XVI swaps crystals for blood and fire, with mixed results
Final Fantasy XVI review: Square Enix's darker, action-driven reinvention delivers stunning Eikon battles and a strong lead, but thin RPG systems and filler.
Good
Editorial score out of 10
Final Fantasy XVI is the series' boldest reinvention in years. It trades turn-based menus and bright crystal fantasy for real-time action and a grim political drama more reminiscent of prestige television than of earlier entries. Its central character is excellent, its biggest battles are breathtaking, and its combat is a genuine pleasure.
- 7.9
- Editorial score
- #105
- Of 116 games reviewed
- 2023
- Released
- 8.9
- Best at: Presentation
Yet in shedding traditional role-playing mechanics, it loses some depth, and its pacing and side content are markedly weaker than its highlights. The result is a fascinating but uneven game.
The game is visually impressive in its set pieces, with superb cinematic direction and enormous scale during Eikon battles.
How it plays
Clive fights alone for most encounters, with occasional companions who act independently and his loyal wolf, Torgal, who can be given simple commands. Combat is fast and stylish, shaped by a combat director with experience on the Devil May Cry series. Clive gains Eikon abilities over time, and equipping three sets at once, each with its own special attacks, allows varied combinations and satisfying juggles.
Eikon battles, in which Clive or other Dominants transform into titanic beings, are extraordinary. These set pieces combine action, cinematic direction and scale in ways few games have attempted, and are among the most memorable moments in the series.
The weaknesses lie elsewhere. Equipment is simple, with few meaningful choices, and there is no party control. Accessibility items allow automatic dodging and attacking, which make the game approachable but also highlight its limited challenge on the default difficulty.

World and story
Valisthea is a land defined by war, politics and injustice, and the story explores themes of slavery, freedom and identity. Clive's journey is compelling, anchored by Ben Starr's strong performance. Supporting characters, especially the grizzled Cid, played by Ralph Ineson, bring warmth and humour.
The Active Time Lore system, which lets players pause cutscenes to read about characters and events relevant to the current scene, is a clever tool for making a complex political narrative more digestible.
Pacing is uneven. After a strong opening, the middle section slows considerably, with long stretches of side quests that involve running errands and talking to non-player characters. These add context, but many are mechanically dull.
Presentation
The game is visually impressive in its set pieces, with superb cinematic direction and enormous scale during Eikon battles. Character models and cutscenes are detailed. Environments, however, often lean on a muted palette of greys and browns, which suits the tone but can feel monotonous.
Masayoshi Soken's soundtrack is a highlight, combining sweeping orchestral themes with intense rock during battles and a few welcome nods to the series' musical history.
Performance on PS5 at launch was criticised for noticeable frame rate drops in combat, especially in the performance-focused mode.
Who it is for
This is ideal for players who enjoy character-action combat and cinematic, mature fantasy storytelling. It may disappoint fans expecting traditional Final Fantasy mechanics, such as party management or turn-based battles, and those who dislike filler side quests. The two story expansions add worthwhile content for players who enjoyed the base game.
What works
- Eikon battles are among the most spectacular set pieces in the series
- Fluid, stylish combat that mixes swordplay with swappable Eikon powers
- Clive Rosfield is a grounded, well-performed and likeable lead
- Active Time Lore helps players track a dense political plot
What doesn’t
- Side quests are largely fetch tasks with little mechanical variety
- Role-playing systems like gear and party control are very thin
- A muted palette and sluggish middle act dampen the momentum
Head to head
- Story
- 8.17.9
- Gameplay
- 7.77.8
- Longevity
- 6.96.8
- Presentation
- 8.98.9
Final Fantasy XVI edges it by 0.4. See them side by side
The verdict
At its peaks, Final Fantasy XVI is spectacular, with some of the best boss battles in the franchise and a strong central character. Thin progression systems, dull side content and a sagging middle act drag down the overall experience, and the score sits just below excellent because the game is so often great in moments and ordinary in between.





