Skip to content
Series reviewExcellent

Gomorrah · 2014

Gomorrah: a crime saga that gives you no one to root for, and dares you to look away

Gomorrah review. Sky Italia's Neapolitan crime drama trades the glamour of the gangster genre for concrete, dialect and dread, and is stronger for it.

Voxizer EditorialSection editor Ignacio Pineda9 min read

Excellent

Editorial score out of 10

Gomorrah is the gangster story with the glamour scraped off. There are no tailored suits, no opera on the soundtrack and no rules of honour for a viewer to admire from a safe distance. There are tower blocks, tracksuits, kitchens with the television on, and young men who will kill for a corner of a car park. The series takes the genre American television made respectable and drags it back to the place Roberto Saviano's book described: the drug markets on the northern edge of Naples, where the Camorra is less a family than an economy.

8.7
Editorial score
#29
Of 109 series reviewed
2014
Released
5
Seasons

That choice makes Gomorrah harder to love than its American cousins and, for long stretches, more gripping. It refuses the viewer a hero, it refuses the comfort of a decent cop or a reforming criminal, and it asks for full attention in a language most of its audience cannot follow without subtitles. What it offers in return is the most coherent world any European crime series has built, and two lead performances that carry five seasons on their shoulders.

The premise

Pietro Savastano runs the drug trade in Secondigliano from a house full of gilt furniture and plastic-wrapped sofas. Ciro Di Marzio, nicknamed the Immortal, is his most capable soldier: clever, ambitious and loyal in the way that ambitious men are loyal, which is provisionally. Pietro's son Genny is soft, spoilt and clearly not ready for anything, and Ciro is handed the job of turning him into an heir. Then Pietro is arrested, a rival clan smells weakness, and the Savastano house has to decide who actually holds power when the man who held it is behind glass.

The opening episodes set out the show's method plainly. The camera is less interested in the big decisions than in what they cost the people who carry them out: the soldier sent to burn a house, the friend who has to choose a side, the woman who has spent decades watching and now intends to act. Maria Pia Calzone's Imma Savastano is one of the series' great early surprises, a wife who turns out to understand the business better than the men around her and who is far more frightening for being so composed.

Saviano's book was reportage, not a novel, and the series keeps that sense of documentary underpinning. The writers' room, led by Stefano Bises with Leonardo Fasoli, Ludovica Rampoldi and Giovanni Bianconi, draws loosely on the real feuds that tore through Secondigliano and Scampia in the 2000s. Nothing here is a reconstruction of a case, but much of it feels as if it could have been.

  1. 2006

    Roberto Saviano publishes Gomorra, his book on the Camorra's economy

  2. 2008

    Matteo Garrone's film adapts the book; it is unrelated to the series

  3. 2014

    The series premieres on Sky Atlantic in Italy on 6 May, and in the UK in August

  4. 2016

    Season two airs; SundanceTV brings the show to American viewers

  5. 2019

    The Immortal, a feature film set within the series' story, reaches Italian cinemas

  6. 2021

    The fifth and final season ends on 17 December

Gomorrah
GomorrahFrame from the official trailer, SundanceTV

Season by season

Gomorrah is best understood as a long story of succession told in five movements. The first season is tight and nearly self-contained, an account of how a clan behaves when its head is removed. The second widens the frame to the other bosses of the city and is the most purely suspenseful run the series ever managed. From the third season on the show changes shape, shifting its weight towards younger crews from the historic centre, and the arc becomes less about one clan's fortunes than about what the system does to anyone who tries to master it.

That later stretch has real rewards, especially in the new characters Arturo Muselli and Cristiana Dell'Anna bring in, but it also repeats itself. Alliances are made in a parked car, tested in a warehouse and broken in a stairwell, and by the fourth season a seasoned viewer can feel the turn coming an episode early. The show never becomes careless, but it does become predictable in rhythm, if rarely in outcome.

The five seasons
SeasonYearEpisodesIn one line
1201412The clan after the patriarch: tight, patient, nearly perfect
2201612The city opens up; the most suspenseful run of the five
3201712New crews from the centre change the show's centre of gravity
4201912Ambitions turn legitimate, with mixed dramatic results
5202110A darker, narrower close to the whole saga
Watch
Gomorrah — trailer

Characters

The series lives or dies on Ciro and Genny, and it lives. Their relationship begins as tutor and pupil, sours into rivalry and keeps returning to something neither of them can name. Gomorrah is shrewd about what loyalty means in a place where every friendship is also a business arrangement: the moments that hurt are not the shootings but the small betrayals before them, a meeting skipped, a name withheld, a smile held a second too long.

In Gomorrah, nobody is a gangster by vocation. They are employees of a market that never closes.

The supporting cast is drawn with the same care. Cristina Donadio's Scianel, a dealer who runs her own piece of territory with a matriarch's appetite, is one of the most memorable characters Italian television has produced. The younger soldiers, with their nicknames, shaved heads and gold chains, are individuals rather than a chorus. What the show does not offer is anyone outside the system with real dramatic weight. The police are a distant weather front; ordinary residents are seen mostly in passing. That is a deliberate choice, and it is the main reason some viewers find the series airless.

Gallery · 3 imagesSky Italia / Cattleya, via TVmaze · Frame from the official trailer, SundanceTV

Performances

Marco D'Amore plays Ciro as a man who thinks three moves ahead and feels about half a move behind, and much of the performance lives in his stillness: the shaved head, the level stare, the pause before he agrees to anything. Salvatore Esposito has the harder job. Genny's transformation from coddled heir to something else entirely could have been a gimmick of costume and haircut, and Esposito makes it a slow change of posture and voice that is entirely convincing.

Fortunato Cerlino gives Pietro Savastano the gravity of a king in exile, and Calzone, as noted, steals whole episodes. Most of the cast are Neapolitan, and the series is performed largely in dialect rather than standard Italian. That lends the acting a texture no amount of direction could fake. It also means that viewers relying on subtitles will miss jokes, insults and shifts of register that native speakers hear at once.

How it watches

Violence
9/10
Frequent, sudden and never stylised
Pace
6/10
Patient in the first season, brisker later
Plot density
7/10
Alliances shift fast; attention is rewarded
Comfort
1/10
No one to like, nowhere to rest

Craft

Stefano Sollima, who supervised the first two seasons and directed several episodes, set the series' look: long lenses, desaturated colour, interiors lit by windows and televisions, exteriors shot in the flat grey light of the Vele di Scampia, the housing blocks that became the show's emblem. Francesca Comencini and Claudio Cupellini, who directed alongside him and continued afterwards, kept the grammar intact, and D'Amore later moved behind the camera without breaking it.

The sound is as important as the image. The Roman band Mokadelic wrote a score of slow, swelling post-rock that sits under scenes rather than commenting on them, and the pop playing on car radios and in kitchens places every scene in a specific, ordinary city. Action is staged with restraint: a killing often takes a few seconds and is shown from a distance, and the cut afterwards is to someone who has to clean it up.

Where it sits

The obvious comparisons are American. Gomorrah has the succession drama of [The Sopranos](/item/the-sopranos), without the therapy or the comedy, and something of the institutional view of [The Wire](/item/the-wire), without the cops or the reformers. Set beside [Narcos](/item/narcos), it is far less interested in the thrill of the trade and far more in its routine. It is closest in spirit to the later Italian wave it helped start, a run of crime series that treat their cities as characters and their criminals as workers.

Head to head

Craft
9.19.5
Story
8.59.6
Characters
8.99.9
Performances
9.09.9

The Sopranos edges it by 1.0. See them side by side

The comparison flatters both shows. The Sopranos is the richer portrait of one man's interior life; Gomorrah is the sharper picture of a whole economy. A viewer who finished the first and wanted something colder, younger and less forgiving has found it here.

For you if

  • Anyone who wants a crime drama about systems rather than heroes
  • Viewers comfortable with subtitles, dialect and slow-building menace
  • Fans of The Sopranos and The Wire who have run out of American options

Not for you if

  • Anyone who needs a character to like before committing to five seasons
  • Viewers who find sustained, matter-of-fact violence hard to sit through
  • Those hoping for the glamour and swagger of the gangster film tradition

The first season is the right place to begin, and the only sensible one. Nearly every later development depends on the relationships it sets up.

What works

  • Neapolitan dialogue and real Scampia locations make every scene feel lived in
  • Marco D'Amore and Salvatore Esposito build a partnership the whole show turns on
  • Stefano Sollima's early episodes set a cold, patient visual language that lasts
  • Violence lands as consequence, never as spectacle to be enjoyed

What doesn’t

  • With no one decent to follow, some viewers will find it hard to care who wins
  • Later seasons repeat the cycle of alliance and betrayal with diminishing surprise
  • Subtitles are not optional, and the dialect resists even Italian speakers
ExcellentHow we score

The verdict

Gomorrah is a crime series with the courage of its subject. It never asks the viewer to admire the people it follows, it never pretends the trade they run is anything other than squalid, and it builds a world so specific in language, architecture and sound that it feels reported rather than invented. The two central performances hold it together from first episode to last. The score stops short of the top tier because the later seasons fall into a rhythm a viewer can anticipate, and because the show's refusal of any outside perspective, admirable as principle, can leave it airless across five seasons. For a viewer willing to meet it on its terms, it is still the most important European crime drama of its decade.

Quick answers

Is Gomorrah worth watching?

Voxizer scores Gomorrah (2014) 8.7 out of 10 — excellent. Gomorrah is a crime series with the courage of its subject. It never asks the viewer to admire the people it follows, it never pretends the trade they run is anything other than squalid, and it builds a world so specific in language, architecture and sound that it feels reported rather than invented.

Who will enjoy Gomorrah?

Anyone who wants a crime drama about systems rather than heroes. Viewers comfortable with subtitles, dialect and slow-building menace. Fans of The Sopranos and The Wire who have run out of American options.

Who should skip Gomorrah?

Anyone who needs a character to like before committing to five seasons. Viewers who find sustained, matter-of-fact violence hard to sit through. Those hoping for the glamour and swagger of the gangster film tradition.

What is Gomorrah like, in short?

A Neapolitan crime drama that trades gangster glamour for concrete, dialect and dread. Ciro and Genny, mentor and heir, are the axis everything else turns around. The first two seasons are the strongest; the later ones repeat the pattern with less surprise. Visual and sound design set a standard Italian television had not reached before.

What readers say

Written by Voxizer members and checked by our moderators before they appear.

Written reviews

–

No written reviews yet

Write a review
9–10
0
7–8.5
0
5–6.5
0
3–4.5
0
0–2.5
0

Nobody has reviewed Gomorrah yet. Be the first.

All reviews →

Verified sources

Published by the Voxizer editorial team — David Abellán, Ignacio Pineda, Pablo Huguet. Section editor for series: Ignacio Pineda.

Revision history

  1. Published

Scores are revised when the facts behind them change, and the change is recorded here. How we score.