Hacks · 2021
Hacks: a sharp two-hander about comedy, ageing and ambition that keeps improving
Our review of Hacks, the HBO Max comedy starring Jean Smart and Hannah Einbinder: witty, warm and biting, with a third season that is its best yet.
Excellent
Editorial score out of 10
Hacks takes a premise that sounds like a formula, a grumpy veteran and a brash newcomer forced to work together, and turns it into one of the most consistently satisfying comedies on television. The show's creators understand both comedy and the people who make it, and they give Jean Smart and Hannah Einbinder material that is funny, bruising and, increasingly, moving.
- 8.6
- Editorial score
- #35
- Of 109 series reviewed
- 2021
- Released
- 3
- Seasons
Over its first three seasons, the series has grown steadily more confident. The third, in which Deborah's career finds a surprising new opportunity, is widely considered the strongest yet.
Her Deborah is imperious, cruel, hilarious and very lonely, and Smart can switch between these states within a sentence.
Story
The first season sets up the partnership as a battle. Deborah, a comic who built a fortune on Las Vegas residencies and home-shopping merchandise, wants to keep her show alive; Ava, an entitled but talented writer, needs work but thinks Deborah's act is out of touch. As they write together, each begins to see the other more clearly, and the season uses the process of drafting jokes to explore art, commerce and the compromises women in comedy have been forced to make.
The second season takes the pair on the road, testing new material in unforgiving venues and pushing their relationship into deeper territory. The third jumps forward in time and shows the partnership from a different angle, then tightens around Deborah's pursuit of a long-denied goal in television. It is sharp about ambition and loyalty, and it builds to an ending that reshapes the dynamic in bold ways. The show's rhythm of rift and reconciliation between its leads is occasionally predictable, but the writing keeps finding new dimensions within it.

Characters and performances
Jean Smart is magnificent. Her Deborah is imperious, cruel, hilarious and very lonely, and Smart can switch between these states within a sentence. Hannah Einbinder, relatively unknown when the series began, holds her own with impressive assurance, making Ava both irritating and deeply sympathetic. Their chemistry is the show's engine.
The supporting cast is strong, if unevenly served. Paul W. Downs and Megan Stalter form a very funny agent-and-assistant pairing, and Carl Clemons-Hopkins gives Marcus a quiet dignity, although his storylines receive less attention in later seasons. Guest stars appear across the run, and several give memorable turns.
Craft
Hacks is precisely written and briskly edited. The dialogue sparkles with jokes that come from character rather than set-ups. The show's depiction of Las Vegas, all opulent mansions and hotel back corridors, is vivid, and the stand-up sequences are staged with a convincing feel for live performance. Visually it is polished and clean without being especially distinctive, which suits the focus on performance.
Who it is for
Hacks will appeal to anyone who loves stand-up comedy, character-driven television or stories about creative partnerships. Its humour is often profane, and it deals frankly with generational politics. Viewers new to the show should start at the beginning, since the third season's power depends on everything that precedes it.
What works
- Jean Smart gives Deborah Vance ferocious wit and hidden vulnerability
- Hannah Einbinder matches her in a genuinely equal double act
- Smart about how comedy is written, performed and sold
- Megan Stalter's Kayla is a reliable source of chaotic laughs
What doesn’t
- Some supporting storylines feel thin beside the central pair
- The push-pull of the leads' relationship can feel cyclical
- Visual style is polished but rarely adventurous
Head to head
- Craft
- 8.49.2
- Story
- 8.38.5
- Characters
- 9.08.9
- Performances
- 9.39.3
Barry edges it by 0.1. See them side by side
The verdict
Hacks earns an 8.6 for two outstanding lead performances, writing that is both hilarious and emotionally intelligent, and a third season that shows a series still growing. Thinner supporting storylines, a somewhat repetitive central push and pull and conventional visual craft stop it reaching the very top tier of television comedy.





