House of X / Powers of X · 2019
House of X / Powers of X rebuilds the X-Men as a nation and a riddle
House of X / Powers of X is Jonathan Hickman's audacious twelve-issue reinvention of the X-Men, brilliant in concept and design, if chilly and schematic.
Excellent
Editorial score out of 10
House of X / Powers of X is the most ambitious reboot of the X-Men since the 1970s, and among the most ambitious event comics Marvel has published in years. Jonathan Hickman takes a franchise that had spent decades cycling through near-extinctions and persecution narratives and asks a different question: what if mutants stopped trying to be tolerated and simply built a country?
- 8.5
- Editorial score
- #36
- Of 53 comics reviewed
- 2019
- Released
- 12
- Issues
The answer is exciting, unsettling and very clever. It is also cold, occasionally airless, and more interested in systems than in the people who live inside them.
Discussion of which details mattered was part of the experience, and the books still reward a careful reread.
Two books, one design
The structure is part of the pleasure. House of X focuses on the present, as Xavier announces the nation of Krakoa to the world, offering miraculous mutant-derived medicines in exchange for recognition and inviting mutants of every stripe, heroes and villains alike, to live there. Powers of X ranges across eras, from the past to a present-day infiltration and a far future in which humans, machines and mutants have followed very different paths.
Read in the intended order, the two series comment on each other. An early revelation reframes decades of continuity, and Hickman's timelines turn the event into a puzzle that readers pored over at the time. Discussion of which details mattered was part of the experience, and the books still reward a careful reread.

Larraz, Silva and Muller
Pepe Larraz draws House of X with enormous scale: floating habitats, sweeping establishing shots of Krakoa, and action scenes with real kinetic force. R.B. Silva's work on Powers of X is cleaner and more precise, well suited to the cooler, more speculative material. The shift between the two styles helps readers keep the timelines distinct, and the colour work supports the idea of Krakoa as a lush, alien paradise.
Tom Muller's design is essential. The series is punctuated by text pages, diagrams and charts, as well as an invented mutant language and new logos, giving the relaunch a unified identity unlike anything else on the stands that year.
Ideas over emotion
The same features that make the series thrilling make it distant. A great deal of worldbuilding lives in those data pages rather than in scenes, and some readers will find it homework. Characters with decades of history, from Cyclops to Jean Grey, appear more as delegates in Hickman's plan than as people with doubts and relationships. Moral questions about Krakoa's alliances and methods are raised with a pleasing ambiguity but largely left to later books.
That is the other issue. The series is a launchpad, and the wider Krakoa era that followed was uneven, with Hickman departing before his long-term plans were resolved. Judged purely as a standalone, it ends on a cliff-edge of possibility rather than a conclusion.
Who it is for
Lapsed X-Men readers who want to see the franchise reimagined will find the most to love, though a basic knowledge of the core characters helps enormously. Fans of Hickman's big, architectural plotting will be delighted; readers who come to superhero comics for emotional character arcs may be less satisfied.
What works
- A genuinely bold reinvention that gives the X-Men a new political premise
- Interlocking timelines reward close reading and rereading
- Pepe Larraz's widescreen spectacle and R.B. Silva's precise figures excel
- Tom Muller's data pages and design make the event feel like a new world
What doesn’t
- Data pages and charts often carry story that the drama should
- Familiar characters are treated as pieces on a board with little inner life
- Its promises depend on follow-up series that did not all deliver
Head to head
- Art
- 8.98.9
- Story
- 8.88.8
- Pacing
- 8.17.6
- Characters
- 7.58.7
Immortal Hulk edges it by 0.1. See them side by side
The verdict
House of X / Powers of X is a bold, intricate and beautifully designed reinvention that changed the direction of an entire line. Its reliance on data pages, cool treatment of beloved characters and dependence on sequels that did not all follow through keep it short of the top tier. An 8.5 reflects an excellent event comic whose ideas outstrip its heart.



