Skip to content
Game reviewExcellent

Lies of P · 2023

Lies of P is the most accomplished FromSoftware-style game not made by FromSoftware

Lies of P review: Round8 Studio's dark Pinocchio soulslike delivers superb bosses, flexible weapon crafting and rich atmosphere, but leans on its influences.

Voxizer EditorialSection editor David Abellán3 min read

Excellent

Editorial score out of 10

Lies of P arrived with a curious premise, a dark soulslike take on Pinocchio, and many expected it to be a derivative imitation. Instead, it proved to be one of the most accomplished games in the genre not made by FromSoftware, with excellent combat, memorable bosses and a distinctive setting.

8.2
Editorial score
#93
Of 116 games reviewed
2023
Released
8.8
Best at: Gameplay

It wears its influences openly, and it rarely innovates beyond them. But its execution is so polished that it earns its place alongside the games it emulates.

The soundtrack is haunting, with orchestral themes and records that can be collected and played in the hotel hub, adding melancholy.

How it plays

Combat blends elements of Bloodborne and Sekiro. P can dodge, block and perform perfect guards, which reduce damage and can break enemy weapons. Charged attacks and fatal attacks, triggered after staggering enemies, add aggression.

The weapon assembly system is a highlight. Blades and handles can be combined to create custom weapons, mixing moves and stats. This allows for creative builds and experimentation.

P's Legion Arm, a mechanical prosthetic, can be swapped for different tools, such as a flamethrower, a grappling hook or a shield, adding tactical options.

Bosses are challenging and dramatic, with multiple phases and aggressive patterns. Some rely on delayed attacks and strict timing, which can feel punishing, especially for players who prefer dodging.

Levels are well designed but mostly linear, with shortcuts and hidden areas. Exploration is less open than in some genre-leading games.

Lies of P
Lies of P

World and story

Krat is a beautifully realised city, blending elegant Belle Époque architecture with dark, industrial elements. Streets, factories, opera houses and cathedrals create a haunting atmosphere.

The story reimagines Pinocchio with themes of humanity, identity and deception. The lying mechanic lets P tell the truth or lie in conversations, influencing his humanity, character relationships and endings. This adds moral complexity and replay value.

Characters such as Geppetto and the enigmatic Sophia add emotional depth, though the narrative can feel convoluted at times.

Watch
Lies of P — trailer

Presentation

Lies of P is visually impressive, with detailed environments, dramatic lighting and grotesque enemy designs. The puppets are particularly unsettling, and bosses are memorable.

The soundtrack is haunting, with orchestral themes and records that can be collected and played in the hotel hub, adding melancholy.

Performance is generally stable, and the game runs well on a range of hardware. A later expansion, Overture, added further story content and bosses.

Gallery · 3 images

Who it is for

This is a natural next step for players who have finished FromSoftware's games and want more of the same demanding rhythm, particularly those who enjoyed the parry-focused duels of Sekiro. Newcomers to the genre will find it tough, since the early bosses give little ground and strict guard timing takes practice. Players who prize open exploration or genuine novelty may find it too faithful to its sources, but anyone drawn to its gothic, clockwork take on a familiar fairy tale will find plenty to admire.

What works

  • Weapon assembly lets blades and handles be mixed for varied builds
  • Challenging, memorable bosses with dramatic multi-phase designs
  • Belle Époque setting brings a fresh, elegant look to dark fantasy
  • Lying mechanic adds intriguing moral choices and multiple endings

What doesn’t

  • Borrows heavily from Bloodborne and Sekiro rather than innovating
  • Perfect guard timing is strict and some attacks feel delayed
  • Linear levels offer less exploration than genre-leading games

Head to head

Story
7.69.0
Gameplay
8.89.6
Longevity
7.89.8
Presentation
8.79.4

Elden Ring edges it by 1.4. See them side by side

ExcellentHow we score

The verdict

Lies of P earns its score through polished, demanding combat, a clever weapon system and a Krat worth getting lost in. It is held back by how closely it follows its influences, by strict parry timing that can make some bosses feel more punishing than fair, and by largely linear levels, but for fans of the genre it is a remarkable and confident achievement.

Quick answers

Is Lies of P worth playing?

Voxizer scores Lies of P (2023) 8.2 out of 10 — excellent. Lies of P earns its score through polished, demanding combat, a clever weapon system and a Krat worth getting lost in. It is held back by how closely it follows its influences, by strict parry timing that can make some bosses feel more punishing than fair, and by largely linear levels, but for fans of the genre it is a remarkable and confident achievement.

What readers say

Written by Voxizer members and checked by our moderators before they appear.

Written reviews

–

No written reviews yet

Write a review
9–10
0
7–8.5
0
5–6.5
0
3–4.5
0
0–2.5
0

Nobody has reviewed Lies of P yet. Be the first.

All reviews →

Verified sources

Published by the Voxizer editorial team — David Abellán, Ignacio Pineda, Pablo Huguet. Section editor for games: David Abellán.

Revision history

  1. Published

Scores are revised when the facts behind them change, and the change is recorded here. How we score.