Skip to content
Comic reviewExcellent

Locke & Key · 2008

Locke & Key: a haunted-house comic that is really about grief, and plays fair to the last door

Locke & Key review. Joe Hill and Gabriel Rodríguez's IDW horror series turns a house of magic keys into a 37-issue story about a family coming apart.

Voxizer EditorialSection editor David Abellán9 min read

Excellent

Editorial score out of 10

Locke & Key opens with a murder and a move, and for its first few issues it reads like a slasher with a fantasy hook. Give it a volume and the hook turns out to be the point. Every magic key in Keyhouse answers a wish a grieving family might have: to step out of your body, to take a painful memory out of your own head, to be somewhere, anywhere, other than here. Joe Hill and Gabriel Rodríguez built a horror series out of those wishes, and then spent six years showing what each one costs.

8.9
Editorial score
#22
Of 53 comics reviewed
2008
Released
9.2
Best at: Art

It is one of the most complete stories American comics produced in its decade, planned as a single arc and finished on its own terms. The violence is real and the opening is rough going, but the series that grows out of it is warm, clever and, by the end, hard to put down for reasons that have little to do with monsters.

Bode is curious, brave and six, and treats the house as the best adventure anyone has ever had, which is exactly why he is the one it notices first.

The premise

Rendell Locke, a school guidance counsellor, is murdered at the family's home in California by a teenager he had counselled. His widow Nina takes the three children, teenage Tyler and Kinsey and six-year-old Bode, across the country to Keyhouse, the old family house in the coastal town of Lovecraft, Massachusetts, where their uncle Duncan has been looking after the place. That is the whole of the first chapter, and Hill handles it without sentiment: the family arrives already broken, and the house is not where they heal.

It is Bode, youngest and least supervised, who finds the first key. Put it in one particular door, walk through, and you step out as a ghost, free to drift through walls while your body lies on the floor behind you. Then he finds the well house, and the voice inside it, which is friendly, and patient, and interested in what else the house might hold. The adults in the family cannot see any of this, and the series makes that blindness a rule of its world rather than a convenience, which matters more and more as the story widens.

Locke & Key
Locke & KeyWelcome to Lovecraft title card and Volume 1 cover, IDW Publishing, via the IDW Publishing YouTube channel

The writing

Hill is a novelist, and his comics scripts read like a novelist learning to trust pictures. The early issues still lean on captions and internal monologue. By the second volume he has stopped explaining and started cutting, letting a panel of Kinsey's face or a page of silent movement carry what a paragraph used to. That change is visible within the series and is part of its pleasure: the book gets better at being a comic as it goes.

His real gift is structural. Each key is introduced with a clear rule, and the rule is never broken for convenience. A key that lets you open someone's head and remove what is inside it is a fantasy device, but it is also a straightforward image of what grief makes people want to do, and Hill writes the consequences of using it as carefully as the thrill. The villain's plans proceed by the same rules the children are learning, which makes the series a mystery as much as a horror story. Readers who go back to the first volume after the last will find the solution there in plain sight.

  1. 2008

    Welcome to Lovecraft #1 is released by IDW on 20 February and sells out in a single day

  2. 2009

    Head Games, the second arc, begins in January; Crown of Shadows follows late in the year

  3. 2011

    Joe Hill wins the Eisner Award for Best Writer for the series

  4. 2013

    Alpha #2 concludes the original run in December, five years and ten months after the first issue

  5. 2015

    All six volumes are adapted as an audio drama for Audible

  6. 2020

    Netflix's television adaptation premieres, running for three seasons until 2022

The writing is not flawless. Some of the adult cast exist mainly to fail to notice things, and a few early school scenes play like a standard teen drama before they earn their place. The dialogue of the teenagers, though, is consistently good: funny, guarded and specific, the way people talk when they are pretending to be fine.

Watch
Locke & Key — trailer

The art

Gabriel Rodríguez trained as an architect, and it shows in Keyhouse itself, a building drawn so consistently from issue to issue that a reader can learn its rooms. His line is clean and controlled, closer to European ligne claire than to the scratchy shadows horror comics usually reach for. The effect is that the horror happens in daylight. When something terrible occurs, it is drawn as clearly as a breakfast table, and there is nowhere for the eye to hide.

The same clarity makes the quiet scenes land. Rodríguez draws faces with a slight cartoon roundness that keeps the children young, which makes what happens to them harder to watch. His page layouts get more ambitious as the series goes on, and the fourth volume's opening issue, "Sparrow", follows Bode in short newspaper-strip tiers drawn as an open homage to Bill Watterson's Calvin and Hobbes, while the older siblings' story runs in conventional pages alongside. It is a formal stunt that also says something true about how differently a six-year-old and two teenagers experience the same bad day.

How it reads

Horror
8/10
Graphic violence, mostly in the first and last volumes
Mystery
8/10
Fairly clued from the first arc onwards
Warmth
7/10
More family drama and comedy than the covers suggest
Pace
6/10
Slower in the middle volumes than at either end
Self-containment
10/10
One story, six volumes, finished

Jay Fotos's colours deserve a mention of their own. Keyhouse is drawn in browns and greys, the town around it in cold coastal blues, and the magic arrives in sudden saturated light. Every key glows a little; you learn to look for it on the page.

Gallery · 3 imagesGabriel Rodríguez inking a Locke & Key illustration, IDW Publishing, via the IDW Publishing YouTube channel · Locke & Key, Volume 2: Head Games — cover art by Gabriel Rodríguez, IDW Publishing, via Open Library · Locke & Key, Volume 3: Crown of Shadows — cover art by Gabriel Rodríguez, IDW Publishing, via Open Library

Characters

The three Locke children are the reason the series works. Tyler blames himself for his father's death and carries it like a weight he refuses to put down. Kinsey wants above all to stop feeling what she feels, and the house is more than willing to help her with that. Bode is curious, brave and six, and treats the house as the best adventure anyone has ever had, which is exactly why he is the one it notices first. Each child grieves in a different register, and Hill and Rodríguez let those differences drive the plot rather than decorate it.

The supporting cast is wider than the opening suggests: friends at school, a teacher with an unexplained connection to the family, Uncle Duncan, who grew up in the house, and a town whose history is tied up with the house in ways that unfold slowly. Nina, the mother, gets the least room, and her story is one of the series' sadder threads for being told largely at the edges of other people's panels.

Pacing and format

The original run is 37 issues across six arcs, and the collected volumes are the natural way to read it now. Each one tells a complete episode and ends at a natural pause, but none of them is a stand-alone story; the six are chapters of a single novel.

The six collected volumes
VolumeIssuesCollectedWhat it adds
1. Welcome to Lovecraft6October 2008The murder, the move, the first keys
2. Head Games6September 2009Memory, school, and a new face in town
3. Crown of Shadows6July 2010The house fights back, and the scale grows
4. Keys to the Kingdom6July 2011Formal experiments and the series at full stride
5. Clockworks6July 2012The history of Keyhouse, told directly
6. Alpha & Omega7February 2014The conclusion, collecting Omega #1–5 and Alpha #1–2

The pacing problem sits in the middle. Head Games and Crown of Shadows are full of good scenes, but they spend issues laying track, and readers who expected the mystery to accelerate after the first volume may feel it idling. From Keys to the Kingdom onward the series rarely wastes a page. Readers who know the Netflix version should treat the comic as a different, darker and tighter work: the show softens most of what the books are about.

The closest companion in the catalogue is Neil Gaiman's The Sandman, another long, finished story where myth and family run through the same doors, though Gaiman's book is more literary and far less frightening.

Head to head

Art
9.28.6
Story
9.19.5
Pacing
8.38.7
Characters
9.09.6

The Sandman edges it by 0.5. See them side by side

For a shorter dose of the same family-in-a-haunted-house grief, the television series The Haunting of Hill House covers similar ground in ten episodes. For teenagers caught in something larger than their town, Paper Girls is lighter company.

For you if

  • Readers who like horror with a beating heart and a solved mystery at the end
  • Anyone who wants a complete, finished comics story rather than an open-ended run
  • Fans of Joe Hill's novels, or of Stephen King's small-town children in peril

Not for you if

  • Readers who cannot face violence against children, even off the page
  • Anyone hoping for the tone of the Netflix series
  • Readers who need a plot to move fast from the first volume to the last

There is only one sensible place to begin, and IDW keeps every volume in print.

What works

  • Every key is a plot device and a metaphor at once, and the series never forgets either
  • Rodríguez's clean line keeps the gore legible and the quiet scenes devastating
  • Three Locke children who grieve in three different, believable ways
  • Six arcs planned as one story, so the early clues pay off in the final volume

What doesn’t

  • The opening volume's violence is blunt enough to put off readers it later rewards
  • Head Games and Crown of Shadows spend issues on set-up before the plot moves
  • Some adult characters exist mainly to not notice what the children see
ExcellentHow we score

The verdict

Locke & Key earns its reputation by doing something few horror series manage: it gets more humane as it gets more frightening. Hill's rules hold from the first key to the last, Rodríguez gives the whole thing a clarity that makes both the scares and the grief impossible to look away from, and the Locke children are drawn and written as people rather than victims. The score stops short of the top tier because the opening volume is harder going than the rest of the series deserves, and because the middle arcs take their time finding the thread. Read through those stretches. The final volumes deliver one of the most satisfying endings of any American comic of its era, and they do it without cheating.

Quick answers

Is Locke & Key worth reading?

Voxizer scores Locke & Key (2008) 8.9 out of 10 — excellent. Locke & Key earns its reputation by doing something few horror series manage: it gets more humane as it gets more frightening. Hill's rules hold from the first key to the last, Rodríguez gives the whole thing a clarity that makes both the scares and the grief impossible to look away from, and the Locke children are drawn and written as people rather than victims.

Who will enjoy Locke & Key?

Readers who like horror with a beating heart and a solved mystery at the end. Anyone who wants a complete, finished comics story rather than an open-ended run. Fans of Joe Hill's novels, or of Stephen King's small-town children in peril.

Who should skip Locke & Key?

Readers who cannot face violence against children, even off the page. Anyone hoping for the tone of the Netflix series. Readers who need a plot to move fast from the first volume to the last.

What is Locke & Key like, in short?

A horror comic about a family's grief, using magic keys as the language for it. Gabriel Rodríguez's art is precise, readable and emotionally exact, from splash pages to faces. The story was planned as one whole, and the clues of the first volume pay off in the sixth. The opening is brutal and the second and third volumes are slow in places.

What readers say

Written by Voxizer members and checked by our moderators before they appear.

Written reviews

–

No written reviews yet

Write a review
9–10
0
7–8.5
0
5–6.5
0
3–4.5
0
0–2.5
0

Nobody has reviewed Locke & Key yet. Be the first.

All reviews →

Verified sources

Published by the Voxizer editorial team — David Abellán, Ignacio Pineda, Pablo Huguet. Section editor for comics: David Abellán.

Revision history

  1. Published

Scores are revised when the facts behind them change, and the change is recorded here. How we score.