Skip to content
Album reviewGood

Man's Best Friend · 2025

Man's Best Friend: Sabrina Carpenter's best-sounding record, and her most single-minded

Man's Best Friend review. Sabrina Carpenter's 2025 album is lavishly played and very funny, though twelve songs on one subject start to blur together.

Voxizer EditorialSection editor Pablo Huguet9 min read

Good

Editorial score out of 10

Man's Best Friend sounds better than any record Sabrina Carpenter has made, and it knows exactly what it wants to say. That is its strength for about two-thirds of its running time and its limit for the rest. Arriving a year after Short n' Sweet, the album that made her one of the biggest pop stars in the world, it narrows the circle of collaborators to three and the subject matter to one: men, and the many ways they let a woman down.

7.6
Editorial score
#42
Of 44 albums reviewed
2025
Released
38:20
Length

The result is a sleek, warm, very funny pop album played by real hands on real instruments, with a singer whose timing is as good as anyone working in the mainstream. It is also a record in which the jokes start to rhyme with each other. The best songs here are among the best of her career. The weaker ones are the same idea with a different chorus, and over twelve tracks the difference starts to show.

At thirty-eight minutes, the shape is easy to hold in mind, and the album never feels padded.

Context

Carpenter spent most of a decade as a working pop artist before her breakthrough. Her early albums came out on Hollywood Records while she was acting on television; she moved to Island for emails i can't send in 2022, and Short n' Sweet turned a run of viral singles into a record that won the Grammy for Best Pop Vocal Album. The pressure on a quick follow-up was obvious, and so was the temptation to repeat the formula with a bigger budget.

What she did instead was shrink the room. Where earlier albums drew on a long list of writers and producers, Man's Best Friend was made by four people: Carpenter, the songwriter Amy Allen, and the producers Jack Antonoff and John Ryan, all three of whom had worked on Short n' Sweet. Carpenter has described the sessions as feeling like a band, with melodies worked out on long walks and arrangements built afterwards. She also took a co-production credit on every track for the first time, and the record's consistency of sound reflects that control.

When the album was teased in June 2025, the clip showed her flicking through records by Donna Summer, ABBA and Dolly Parton before landing on her own. It is a fair map of what follows. Summer is in the disco pulse of "Tears", ABBA in the bright, minor-key melancholy of several choruses, and Parton, whose [Jolene](/item/jolene) remains the model for a funny-sad song about another woman's man, in the country inflections that run through the whole thing.

  1. 2015

    Debut album Eyes Wide Open released on Hollywood Records

  2. 2022

    emails i can't send, her first album for Island Records

  3. 2024

    Short n' Sweet becomes her commercial breakthrough

  4. Jun 2025

    "Manchild" released as the lead single; album and cover revealed days later

  5. Aug 2025

    Man's Best Friend released; debuts at number one in the UK and the US

  6. 2026

    Six nominations at the 68th Grammy Awards, including Album of the Year

Man's Best Friend
Man's Best FriendIsland Records, from the official "Tears" video, via YouTube

The songs

"Manchild" opens the record and states its thesis in under four minutes: a galloping, country-tinged pop song about a grown man who cannot do the simplest things, delivered with more exasperated affection than contempt. Its credits put sitar and a phin alongside the banjo, and the result is a road song that keeps swerving. It went to number one in three countries for good reason. It is the cleanest version of the album's joke.

"Tears" follows as a pastiche of late-1970s disco in the Donna Summer line, built around the gag that basic male competence is the most arousing thing imaginable. It is short, tight and very funny. "My Man on Willpower" is the other early highlight, a slow groove about a partner who has suddenly, suspiciously found self-control, and it shows Carpenter at her most precise as a comic writer: the premise, the escalation and the payoff all arrive on schedule.

The middle stretch is where the formula shows. "Sugar Talking", "Nobody's Son" and "Never Getting Laid" are each well made, and each a variation on a man who talks better than he behaves. "Nobody's Son" has the sharpest production of the three. "Never Getting Laid" has the best title. None of them adds much to what the first three tracks established, and on a first listen they can run together.

Where to start
TrackWhy
ManchildThe thesis in one song, and the album's country side at its brightest
TearsDisco pastiche with the record's best single joke
We Almost Broke Up Again Last NightThe soft-rock heart of the album, and its most rueful lyric
Go Go JuiceBanjo, mandolin and slide guitar on a honky-tonk drinking song
House TourThe most purely fun track, a disco-pop double entendre

The second half recovers by changing texture rather than subject. "We Almost Broke Up Again Last Night" is the record's softest moment, an acoustic soft-rock song about a couple stuck on a loop, and one of the few places where the narrator turns the critique on herself. "Go Go Juice" is an honest-to-goodness honky-tonk number, with Carpenter on banjo and Antonoff on mandolin. "When Did You Get Hot?" is a brisk joke that is over in two and a half minutes. "House Tour" is the most purely joyful thing on the album, and its innuendo is nimble enough to survive repeated plays.

Watch
Man's Best Friend — trailer

Production

This is where the album earns most of its score. Antonoff and Ryan produce different tracks, sometimes together, and the credits show the division: Antonoff's songs lean on acoustic guitars, Mellotron and glockenspiel, while Ryan's are built on bass, keys and drums he often plays himself. What unites them is that the credits list players rather than programmers. Violins, saxophones, flute, trumpet, pedal and slide guitar turn up across the record, and the band sound gives even the slighter songs a pulse.

The mix keeps the vocal at the front, so every syllable of every joke is audible. That is a deliberate choice and the right one for a singer whose appeal rests on delivery. It also means there is no fog to hide in: when a lyric is thin, the production makes it more obvious, not less.

How it sits

Energy
7/10
Mid-tempo grooves with a few genuine dance-floor moments
Intimacy
5/10
Close-miked and personal, but rarely unguarded
Density
7/10
Busy arrangements that never crowd the vocal
Accessibility
9/10
Hooks first, and nothing longer than four minutes
Gallery · 3 imagesIsland Records, from the official "House Tour" video, via YouTube · Island Records, from the official "Manchild" video, via YouTube · Island Records, from the official "Tears" video, via YouTube

Performance

Carpenter's voice is light, agile and very controlled, and she uses it like a comic actor. She knows exactly how long to hold a pause before a punchline, when to drop into a near-speaking register, and when to let a chorus open up so the melody carries a line that would read as crude on paper. On "Tears" and "House Tour" she sounds as if she is having the time of her life. On "We Almost Broke Up Again Last Night" she pulls back, and the tenderness is real.

The limit is range of feeling rather than range of voice. Because so much of the album is played for a knowing grin, the moments that ask for sincerity have to work harder to be believed. The closing ballad, "Goodbye", with its flutes and saxophones, comes closest to letting the mask slip, and it is a good place to end. A record with two or three more moments like it would have been a stronger one.

The cover and the conversation

No account of the album can skip its artwork, though it matters less to the music than the debate suggested. The original cover, revealed in June 2025, shows Carpenter on her hands and knees while a man outside the frame holds her hair. Some commentators and a domestic-abuse charity called it regressive; others read it as satire of exactly the dynamic the songs mock. Carpenter defended the image as being about who holds control, and later issued alternate covers for direct-to-consumer editions, one of which she joked was "approved by God".

Read alongside the songs, the cover is of a piece with the record's method: a provocation designed to make the listener laugh, wince and look again. Whether that lands depends on the listener, as it does throughout.

Sequencing and cohesion

The album asks to be heard in order, and the request is fair. The first three songs set up the joke, the middle tests its limits, and the back half gets out of the corner by changing genre, tempo and tone. At thirty-eight minutes, the shape is easy to hold in mind, and the album never feels padded.

Where it falls short is in the thematic sameness that sequencing cannot fix. Short n' Sweet had a similar subject but more variety in the narrator's mood; here the stance is fixed, and the album's world is narrower for it. Set against Antonoff's work on [The Tortured Poets Department](/review/the-tortured-poets-department-review), which sprawls in the opposite direction, Man's Best Friend is the more disciplined record and the less ambitious one.

Head to head

Cohesion
7.46.2
Production
8.66.4
Performance
8.27.5
Songwriting
7.07.0

Man's Best Friend edges it by 0.8. See them side by side

Who, then, is this album for? Mostly the audience that already found Carpenter, with a few new doors opened for listeners who came up on the 1970s records she borrows from.

For you if

  • Anyone who loved Short n' Sweet and wanted it to sound richer and stranger
  • Listeners who enjoy pop that is played by a band and mixed for the voice
  • Fans of ABBA, Donna Summer and 1970s soft rock looking for a modern take

Not for you if

  • Anyone who finds a steady diet of innuendo wearing rather than funny
  • Listeners who want an album to open up emotionally as it goes
  • Anyone hoping for a change of subject after the last record

For a first listen, start where the album starts and let it run. The singles make the case quickly, and the second half rewards the patience.

What works

  • Live-band arrangements with banjo, sitar, saxophones and strings in place of loops
  • Carpenter's comic timing lands punchlines most pop singers would rush
  • "Manchild", "Tears" and "House Tour" are three distinct ways into the same joke
  • At under forty minutes it never outstays its welcome

What doesn’t

  • Nearly every song chases the same subject, so the middle of the record blurs
  • The innuendo sometimes stands in for a finished lyric rather than crowning one
  • Few moments drop the wink long enough to let a feeling land on its own
GoodHow we score

The verdict

Man's Best Friend is a confident, beautifully played pop record by an artist who has worked out exactly what she does well. The production is the best of her career, the performances are sharp and warm, and at least five of these songs belong among her strongest. What holds the score in the high sevens is the writing's single-mindedness: twelve variations on one disappointment make for a record that is consistently enjoyable but rarely surprising after its first third. It is a better-sounding album than Short n' Sweet and a slightly less varied one, and for most listeners that trade will be worth making. The next step, if Carpenter wants it, is a record that lets the joke rest long enough to say something it cannot.

Quick answers

Is Man's Best Friend worth listening to?

Voxizer scores Man's Best Friend (2025) 7.6 out of 10 — good. Man's Best Friend is a confident, beautifully played pop record by an artist who has worked out exactly what she does well. The production is the best of her career, the performances are sharp and warm, and at least five of these songs belong among her strongest.

Who will enjoy Man's Best Friend?

Anyone who loved Short n' Sweet and wanted it to sound richer and stranger. Listeners who enjoy pop that is played by a band and mixed for the voice. Fans of ABBA, Donna Summer and 1970s soft rock looking for a modern take.

Who should skip Man's Best Friend?

Anyone who finds a steady diet of innuendo wearing rather than funny. Listeners who want an album to open up emotionally as it goes. Anyone hoping for a change of subject after the last record.

What is Man's Best Friend like, in short?

A tighter, richer-sounding follow-up to Short n' Sweet, built by the same small team. The arrangements, from banjo and sitar to saxophone and flute, are the album's real surprise. Carpenter's delivery sells lines that would fall flat in other hands. One subject across twelve songs means the middle third repeats itself.

What readers say

Written by Voxizer members and checked by our moderators before they appear.

Written reviews

–

No written reviews yet

Write a review
9–10
0
7–8.5
0
5–6.5
0
3–4.5
0
0–2.5
0

Nobody has reviewed Man's Best Friend yet. Be the first.

All reviews →

Verified sources

Published by the Voxizer editorial team — David Abellán, Ignacio Pineda, Pablo Huguet. Section editor for albums: Pablo Huguet.

Revision history

  1. Published

Scores are revised when the facts behind them change, and the change is recorded here. How we score.