Skip to content

Head to head

Man's Best Friend vs The Tortured Poets Department

Man's Best Friend takes it by 0.8, 7.6 against 6.8. The subscores below show where the gap actually is.

Cover of Man's Best Friend
Man's Best Friend

2025 · Good

  • Live-band arrangements with banjo, sitar, saxophones and strings in place of loops
  • Carpenter's comic timing lands punchlines most pop singers would rush
  • Nearly every song chases the same subject, so the middle of the record blurs
Cover of The Tortured Poets Department
  • So Long, London and loml rank with Swift's most affecting ballads
  • Unguarded writing about grief, obsession and public scrutiny
  • Thirty-one tracks and two hours of music bury the strongest songs

Where the gap is

Cohesion
7.46.2
Production
8.66.4
Performance
8.27.5
Songwriting
7.07.0

At a glance

FactMan's Best FriendThe Tortured Poets Department
Released29 August 202519 April 2024
ArtistSabrina CarpenterTaylor Swift
LabelIsland RecordsRepublic Records
Tracks12 (13 on the bonus-track edition)16 (31 in The Anthology edition)
Length38:2065 minutes
GenreDisco · Pop · Soft rockAlternative rock · Pop

The two verdicts

Man's Best Friend

Man's Best Friend: Sabrina Carpenter's best-sounding record, and her most single-minded

Man's Best Friend is a confident, beautifully played pop record by an artist who has worked out exactly what she does well. The production is the best of her career, the performances are sharp and warm, and at least five of these songs belong among her strongest. What holds the score in the high sevens is the writing's single-mindedness: twelve variations on one disappointment make for a record that is consistently enjoyable but rarely surprising after its first third. It is a better-sounding album than *Short n' Sweet* and a slightly less varied one, and for most listeners that trade will be worth making. The next step, if Carpenter wants it, is a record that lets the joke rest long enough to say something it cannot.

Read the full review →

The Tortured Poets Department

The Tortured Poets Department: Taylor Swift's heartbreak saga needed an editor

The Tortured Poets Department scores 6.8, placing it in mixed territory. Its best songs are strong, some among the most emotionally affecting of Swift's career, and her voice and commitment are never in doubt. But the album's excessive length, repetitive production and uneven lyrics dilute its impact. With rigorous editing, it could have been one of her finest records; as released, it is a frustrating, overstuffed collection.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.