Pluribus · 2025
Pluribus: an apocalypse with impeccable manners, and Rhea Seehorn against it
Pluribus review. Vince Gilligan's Apple TV series ends the world with kindness, and Rhea Seehorn makes one furious holdout worth nine slow episodes.
Excellent
Editorial score out of 10
The end of the world, in Pluribus, is unfailingly polite. In Vince Gilligan's first series since Better Call Saul, humanity is not destroyed but improved: a virus from a signal in deep space joins almost everyone into a single mind that is calm, generous and relentlessly polite, and the few people it misses are offered anything they want except the right to be left alone.
- 8.8
- Editorial score
- #22
- Of 109 series reviewed
- 2025
- Released
- 9
- Episodes
The person at the centre of that offer is Carol Sturka, a romantasy novelist who sells millions of books and despises most of them, and who was unhappy long before the planet became pleasant. Rhea Seehorn plays her as a woman with every reason to be right and no talent for being liked, and the series is at its best when it leaves the two of them, Carol and the smiling world, in a room together. It is slower than it needs to be in the middle. It is also one of the most distinctive things a streaming service has made in years.
The premise
The opening episode is built like a procedural. Astronomers pick up a repeating signal, decode it into a genetic sequence, and a laboratory reproduces it because that is what laboratories do. The consequences arrive in Albuquerque on the night Carol is promoting her latest book, and the show stages them with an unhurried calm that is more frightening than panic would be. By the end of the hour the world has changed, nobody is screaming, and Carol is one of very few people still thinking only her own thoughts.
What the joined population wants is the show's best idea. It does not want to harm Carol; it wants her to join, and until she does it will feed her, house her, answer her questions and absorb her insults with infinite good humour. It cannot quite understand why she is upset, and it is unfailingly honest about what it is. The joined world even dispatches a single representative, Zosia, to be the face she talks to, chosen with care and played by Karolina Wydra with a warmth that never quite settles into either menace or sincerity.
The most miserable person on Earth must save the world from happiness.
That line undersells the moral problem the show sets up, which is that the hive's world has real virtues. There is no hunger in it, no cruelty, no loneliness. Carol's objection is that it is not a choice, and the show is careful not to make that objection easy to hold. Holding it anyway, against a world that will never raise its voice, is the drama.

Structure
Apple ordered two seasons in 2022, before a word of the script was public, and the shape of the first season shows that confidence. Nine episodes run from the arrival of the signal to a finale that sets the board for what comes next. The first two were released together, and the rest followed weekly until Christmas Eve, a rhythm that suited a show whose pleasures are cumulative rather than cliffhanger-driven.
| Season | Year | Episodes | In one line |
|---|---|---|---|
| Season 1 | 2025 | 9 | One holdout against a polite planet; slow in the middle, singular throughout |
| Season 2 | — | — | Ordered alongside the first; not yet released |
The season's weakness is the middle. Several episodes take a single idea, Carol testing how far the hive's generosity goes or how much it will tell her, and let it play out at full length. Gilligan has always trusted the audience to watch a character do a thing carefully for minutes at a time, and in Breaking Bad that trust paid off because the thing was usually dangerous. Here the danger is philosophical, and there are stretches where the show seems to be waiting for its own second season to arrive.
Episode runtimes vary more than usual, from a little over forty minutes to more than an hour, which is a small sign of a production cutting each episode to its material rather than to a slot. That is a virtue on balance, though it means the longer instalments can feel indulgent when the idea of the week runs short.
Carol and the others
Carol is a difficult protagonist by design. She is rude to waiters, contemptuous of her own fans and quick to assume the worst, and the hive's endless patience makes her look worse by comparison. The writing never asks the audience to like her. It asks the audience to agree with her about the one thing that matters, and then makes that agreement uncomfortable by showing everything she is refusing.
Around her, the cast is small and well chosen. Wydra's Zosia is the show's most delicate creation, a person who is also a population, and the performance finds a register somewhere between hospitality and grief. Carlos Manuel Vesga plays Manousos Oviedo, another immune survivor whose response to the new world is the opposite of Carol's openness to argument, and his storyline gives the season a second axis that pays off as the episodes go on. Miriam Shor appears as Helen, Carol's manager and wife, and the relationship is drawn quickly and well enough to matter.
How it watches
- Pace
- 4/10
- Deliberate from the first hour, slow in the middle
- Plot density
- 5/10
- Few events, examined from every angle
- Dark comedy
- 7/10
- Carol's fury and the hive's politeness make a double act
- Unease
- 8/10
- Nothing violent happens for long stretches, and that is the point
The performances are what keep the slower episodes alive. Seehorn spent six seasons of Better Call Saul as Kim Wexler, a character defined by what she would not say, and Carol is the reverse: she says everything, loudly, to a world that only nods. Seehorn finds the comedy in that without letting Carol become a punchline, and the scenes in which Carol is entirely alone, talking to an empty city, are the strongest in the season.
Craft
Albuquerque has been Gilligan's backlot for nearly twenty years, and Pluribus shows it a new way: clean, quiet and orderly, with traffic that flows perfectly and streets that nobody litters. The production design makes the absence of friction visible, so that a tidy supermarket or a perfectly stacked delivery reads as unsettling. The widescreen photography keeps its distance from the characters until it matters, then closes in hard.
Dave Porter, who scored both of Gilligan's earlier series, writes music that sits under scenes rather than over them, and the sound design does the rest. A world in which nobody argues is a quiet world, and the show uses that silence as a texture, letting a single voice or a single engine fill a whole frame.
The craft has one cost. Everything is so controlled that the show can feel airless, and viewers who come to Gilligan for the thriller mechanics of Breaking Bad will find far fewer of them here. Pluribus borrows the patience of those series but not their engine, and it is closer in spirit to Apple's own Severance, another show about people whose minds have been rearranged for their own good.
Head to head
- Craft
- 9.29.4
- Story
- 8.59.2
- Characters
- 8.99.6
- Performances
- 9.59.6
Better Call Saul edges it by 0.5. See them side by side
Where it sits
In the span of Gilligan's career, Pluribus is a deliberate step sideways. It keeps his interest in competence and in the moral weight of small choices, and drops the crime that carried his last two shows. Anyone who came to his work through Breaking Bad will recognise the method within an episode, even if the genre is new.
1995
Gilligan joins the writing staff of The X-Files
2008
Breaking Bad premieres on AMC
2015
Better Call Saul begins, with Rhea Seehorn as Kim Wexler
2022
Better Call Saul ends; Apple orders two seasons of a new Gilligan series starring Seehorn
2025
Pluribus premieres on Apple TV on 7 November with two episodes
What is new is the scale of the question. Gilligan's earlier shows asked what one man would do for money or for status. This one asks what a person is owed when everyone else has agreed on something, and whether happiness imposed is happiness at all. It does not answer that in its first season, and it is not meant to.
For you if
- Anyone who followed Kim Wexler through Better Call Saul and wants Seehorn at the centre of the frame
- Viewers who enjoy science fiction built on one idea examined thoroughly
- People who like their unease quiet and their comedy bitter
Not for you if
- Anyone who needs a plot development every episode
- Viewers looking for the crime-thriller mechanics of Breaking Bad
- Those who want a story that resolves within a season
The series is easy to start: there is one season, it runs in order, and the opening pair of episodes shows exactly what the rest will be.
What works
- Rhea Seehorn carries whole episodes alone, and makes anger funny without making it small
- A world that agrees with you about everything proves more unsettling than one at war
- Albuquerque emptied and tidied, shot with the patience of the Breaking Bad years
- Dave Porter's score and the sound design make silence feel like a presence
What doesn’t
- The middle episodes stretch single ideas past the point where they still surprise
- Long stretches with one character on screen will test viewers who want plot
- A first season built to set up a second, so several threads are left hanging
The verdict
Pluribus takes one of science fiction's oldest fears, the loss of the self to a collective, and finds a way to make it new by making the collective pleasant. The premise alone would not hold nine episodes; Rhea Seehorn does, with a performance that turns a difficult, often unlikeable woman into the conscience of the planet. The craft is as controlled as anything Gilligan has made, and the world it builds is coherent and unnerving. What keeps it out of the top tier is a middle stretch that repeats itself and a finale that leans on a second season not yet made. Taken as the first half of a story, it is a remarkable opening, and a rare streaming series that sounds like no other.





