Better Call Saul · 2015
Better Call Saul: the spin-off that became a tragedy to rival its parent
Our review of Better Call Saul, the Breaking Bad prequel from Vince Gilligan and Peter Gould: patient, precise and heartbreaking, with a superb Rhea Seehorn.
Essential
Editorial score out of 10
When Better Call Saul was announced, it was easy to imagine a light, disposable spin-off built around one of Breaking Bad's most quotable supporting characters. What Vince Gilligan and Peter Gould made instead is a slow, meticulous and profoundly sad drama about a man who keeps choosing the worst version of himself. Many viewers and critics now rank it alongside its predecessor, and some above it.
- 9.3
- Editorial score
- #9
- Of 109 series reviewed
- 2015
- Released
- 6
- Seasons
Its virtues are patience and precision. Its central flaw, for some, is the same patience: this is a series that takes years to arrive where you know it must go.
Brief black-and-white scenes set after the events of Breaking Bad frame the whole series and give it an elegiac shape.
Story
The first seasons are built around Jimmy's relationship with his brother Chuck, a revered lawyer who cannot believe that Jimmy has changed. It is a legal drama, a sibling drama and a character study all at once, and the conflict between the brothers is some of the most painfully human writing in modern television. Running alongside it is Mike Ehrmantraut's story, which gradually draws the series into the cartel world of Breaking Bad and introduces figures including Tony Dalton's charismatic, terrifying Lalo Salamanca.
The two strands do not always feel equally urgent. Mike's plot is superbly crafted but can seem like a separate show until the threads converge. When they do, in the later seasons, the tension is almost unbearable. Brief black-and-white scenes set after the events of Breaking Bad frame the whole series and give it an elegiac shape.

Characters and performances
Bob Odenkirk's performance is a revelation. He keeps Jimmy's charm and humour intact while letting viewers see the hurt and resentment beneath, so that every step towards Saul feels both inevitable and avoidable. Rhea Seehorn's Kim Wexler, a character who never appeared in Breaking Bad, becomes the soul of the series: controlled, brilliant and increasingly drawn to the thrill of bending rules. Her scenes with Odenkirk are the show's highest achievement. Michael McKean, Jonathan Banks, Giancarlo Esposito and Patrick Fabian all give work of exceptional depth.
Craft
Few series are as visually deliberate. Colour, framing and costume carry meaning, and long wordless sequences, such as Mike methodically dismantling a car or Jimmy preparing a scheme, are gripping precisely because they are so exact. The directors favour unusual angles and patient takes, and the use of montage is often witty. The New Mexico landscapes, familiar from the earlier show, are shot with fresh beauty and menace.
Who it is for
Breaking Bad fans will find endless rewards, but the series stands on its own and can be watched first. The pace of the early seasons requires commitment. Viewers who enjoy character drama over action will find it the more satisfying of the two shows.
What works
- Rhea Seehorn's Kim Wexler is one of television's great characters
- Bob Odenkirk makes a comic figure genuinely tragic
- Meticulous visual storytelling rewards close attention
- Ties into Breaking Bad without depending on nostalgia
What doesn’t
- The early seasons move slowly and test casual viewers
- The cartel storyline sometimes feels separate from Jimmy's story
Head to head
- Craft
- 9.49.2
- Story
- 9.28.3
- Characters
- 9.68.5
- Performances
- 9.69.0
Better Call Saul edges it by 0.8. See them side by side
The verdict
Better Call Saul scores 9.3 for writing and performances of rare subtlety, a character in Kim Wexler who elevates everything around her, and visual craft that sets a standard for the medium. Its deliberate early pacing and occasionally disconnected cartel plot hold it a fraction below the all-time landmarks, but as a portrait of a man losing himself, it is close to peerless.





