Skip to content

Head to head

Better Call Saul vs Mr. Robot

Better Call Saul takes it by 0.8, 9.3 against 8.5. The subscores below show where the gap actually is.

Cover of Better Call Saul
Better Call Saul

2015 · Essential

  • Rhea Seehorn's Kim Wexler is one of television's great characters
  • Bob Odenkirk makes a comic figure genuinely tragic
  • The early seasons move slowly and test casual viewers
Cover of Mr. Robot
Mr. Robot

2015 · Excellent

  • Rami Malek makes Elliot's isolation and paranoia deeply affecting
  • Hacking is depicted with unusual care for technical plausibility
  • The second season is slow and deliberately confusing

Where the gap is

Craft
9.49.2
Story
9.28.3
Characters
9.68.5
Performances
9.69.0

At a glance

FactBetter Call SaulMr. Robot
Released8 February 201524 June 2015
Created byVince Gilligan, Peter GouldSam Esmail
StarringBob Odenkirk, Jonathan Banks, Michael McKeanRami Malek, Christian Slater, Portia Doubleday
NetworkAMCUSA Network
Seasons64
Episodes6345
GenreDrama · CrimeDrama · Crime · Suspense

The two verdicts

Better Call Saul

Better Call Saul: the spin-off that became a tragedy to rival its parent

Better Call Saul scores 9.3 for writing and performances of rare subtlety, a character in Kim Wexler who elevates everything around her, and visual craft that sets a standard for the medium. Its deliberate early pacing and occasionally disconnected cartel plot hold it a fraction below the all-time landmarks, but as a portrait of a man losing himself, it is close to peerless.

Read the full review →

Mr. Robot

Mr. Robot: a paranoid, formally daring thriller for the surveillance age

Mr. Robot earns an 8.5 for Rami Malek's superb performance, Sam Esmail's daring direction and a story that grows into a moving examination of trauma and connection. Its sluggish second season, uneven supporting storylines and occasional over-reliance on reveals keep it from the highest tier, but it remains one of the most original dramas of its decade.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.