Six Feet Under · 2001
Six Feet Under: a family drama that opens every hour with a death and still finds the joke
Six Feet Under review. Alan Ball's HBO drama about a family of Los Angeles undertakers is funny, raw and uneven, and still the best television about grief.
Essential
Editorial score out of 10
No television drama has been more honest about the fact that everyone dies than Six Feet Under, and none has been honest in a less solemn way. Every episode opens on a stranger's last minutes, frequently ridiculous, before the body arrives at a family-run funeral home in Los Angeles where nobody is coping with their own lives, let alone anyone else's grief. The trick Alan Ball pulled off across five seasons is that the morbid frame never curdles into gimmick. It becomes the way the show thinks.
- 9.1
- Editorial score
- #13
- Of 109 series reviewed
- 2001
- Released
- 5
- Seasons
That is not the same as saying it is consistent. The run from 2001 to 2005 includes some of the finest family drama on American television and some of the most exhausting, sometimes in the same episode. What keeps the show worth recommending, two decades on, is that its failures and its triumphs come from the same place: a refusal to make its people easier to like than they are.
The premise
Nathaniel Fisher, owner of Fisher & Sons, is killed on Christmas Eve on his way to collect his elder son from the airport. Nate, who left home years earlier precisely to avoid the family trade, comes back for the funeral and finds himself a partner in it alongside his brother David, the son who stayed, embalmed and kept the books. Their mother Ruth is left with a house full of people she has never quite managed to talk to, and their sister Claire, still at school, is left with the sense that she was the last to be told anything.
Ball came to the show straight from the screenplay for American Beauty, and the family resemblance is there in the suburban unhappiness and the flashes of surreal comedy. The difference is length. A film can satirise a family; a series has to live with one. Over sixty-odd hours the Fishers stop being types and become people a viewer knows the moods of, which is exactly what the show's format of death, funeral, aftermath is designed to test, episode after episode.
1999
Alan Ball's screenplay for American Beauty reaches cinemas
2001
Six Feet Under premieres on HBO on 3 June, with a pilot Ball wrote and directed
2002
A second season deepens the show and confirms it as an HBO flagship
2004
The fourth and least settled season airs over the summer
2005
The final episode is broadcast on 21 August

Structure, season by season
The cold open is the show's signature and its spine. Someone dies, often absurdly, a title card gives the name and the dates, and the Fishers spend the next hour preparing that person for burial while their own lives echo, contradict or ignore the theme the death has raised. In the first two seasons this structure is close to perfect. The clients' families are a mirror the Fishers rarely see themselves in, and the show gets its best jokes and its most painful scenes from the gap.
From the third season the client-of-the-week device loosens and the serial drama takes over. That brings bigger swings in the main storylines, and a run of episodes in the middle of the show that ask a lot of a viewer's patience: relationships break and reset, arguments circle, and several characters spend long stretches making the same mistake in slightly different rooms. The fourth season is the most divisive. The fifth pulls the threads back together with a focus the show had not shown for some time, and the closing hour is still widely discussed as one of the best endings television has produced. Nothing about it is spoiled here; its power depends on arriving at it the long way round.
| Season | Year | Episodes | In one line |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 2001 | 13 | The format at its cleanest; funny, strange and sure of itself |
| 2 | 2002 | 13 | Darker and more confident; the cast becomes an ensemble |
| 3 | 2003 | 13 | Bigger serial swings, some brilliant and some trying |
| 4 | 2004 | 12 | The least settled run, with its strongest material in David's story |
| 5 | 2005 | 12 | A deliberate, gathering final season that earns its ending |
The Fishers and the people around them
The show's real achievement is that nobody in the family is the audience's proxy. Nate is charming and evasive, a man who believes his restlessness is depth. David is rigid, kind, furious and closeted at the start, in a relationship with Keith, a police officer, that the show treats with the same seriousness as any heterosexual romance on television at the time. That was rare in 2001, and the arc David is given across five seasons remains the show's most complete portrait of a person changing.
Ruth is the surprise. Introduced as a pinched, dutiful widow, she becomes the show's comic heart and its most quietly radical figure, a woman in late middle age who discovers, with alarm, that she still wants things. Claire's adolescence is drawn without the softening most series apply to teenage characters: she is sulky, talented, cruel to people who love her and capable of startling perception. Brenda Chenowith, the woman Nate meets on the plane home, is the most provocative of the lot, sharp and self-destructive, and the character on whom a viewer's tolerance for the show tends to be decided.
A funeral home is the only place where a family's grief and its business plan are the same document.
Around them, Federico Diaz, the restorative artist who rebuilds faces for open caskets, gives the show its working-class counterweight: he wants a share of the business and a stable home, and his ambitions are as legitimate as anyone's. The dead themselves also return, in conversations the living imagine having with them. Early on these scenes are inspired, the father turning up in the embalming room to needle his sons. By the later seasons they become a tic, a shortcut to an inner life the actors were already showing perfectly well.
Performances
The casting is close to faultless. Frances Conroy finds comedy in stillness that most actors would need a line to reach, and her timing turns Ruth's small evasions into some of the most quotable moments in the show. Michael C. Hall plays David's control as a pressure system; when it gives, it gives all at once, and it is easy to see in this role why he went on to carry *Dexter*. Lauren Ambrose takes Claire from high school into her twenties without a false step.
Peter Krause has the hardest job, because Nate is written as a man who is hard to root for, and he plays the charm and the selfishness without asking for sympathy. Rachel Griffiths makes Brenda brilliant and exhausting at once, which is the point. Richard Jenkins, as the father glimpsed in memory and imagination, does a great deal with a handful of scenes.
How it watches
- Pace
- 6/10
- Patient; episodes breathe rather than race
- Plot density
- 6.5/10
- Built on character, not twists
- Dark comedy
- 8/10
- The cold opens are often very funny
- Emotional weight
- 9.5/10
- Few dramas ask this much of a viewer
- Comfort
- 3/10
- Not a show to have on in the background
Craft
HBO gave Ball the room to shoot in a way that network drama of the time rarely allowed: long dialogue scenes, silence, and a visual palette that moves from the sunlit Los Angeles exteriors to the greenish strip lights of the prep room. Thomas Newman's main theme, plucked and slightly off-kilter over a title sequence of hands, crows and a gurney fading to white, is one of the most recognisable openings of its era and sets the tone in under a minute.
The writing room, with Ball overseeing throughout, is strongest when it trusts small moments: a family dinner that goes wrong, an argument about flower arrangements. It is weakest when it reaches for event storytelling, and the show's reliance on fantasy sequences and visitations from the dead can feel like a crutch by the middle seasons. Those are the excesses of a show willing to try things, and they cost it less than caution would have.
Where it sits
Six Feet Under arrived two years after The Sopranos and alongside it as proof that HBO's drama could be about something other than crime. Where Tony Soprano's family is held together by power, the Fishers are held together by inheritance and proximity, and the show's subject is not violence but the ordinary work of going on. Read alongside the same channel's gangster saga, it looks like that show's opposite number: quieter, more domestic and more willing to be openly tender. The two make a natural double bill.
Head to head
- Craft
- 9.09.5
- Story
- 8.79.6
- Characters
- 9.59.9
- Performances
- 9.49.9
The Sopranos edges it by 0.6. See them side by side
It also pairs, unexpectedly well, with *Hamnet*, another work about a family reshaped by a loss it cannot discuss. For another route into the same era of prestige television, *Mad Men* is the more polished show, though it rarely risks as much.
For you if
- Viewers who want character drama that takes years to pay off, and does
- Anyone drawn to grief, family and mortality handled with humour
- Admirers of ensemble acting, especially Frances Conroy and Michael C. Hall
Not for you if
- Anyone looking for plot momentum or a mystery to solve
- Viewers who find self-absorbed characters hard company over many hours
- Anyone currently grieving who wants comfort rather than recognition
The first season is the right test. If the opening run of cold opens and family arguments lands, the rest of the show will reward the time; if it does not, the later seasons will not change your mind.
What works
- The cold-open death in each episode sets a theme the family then lives out
- Frances Conroy's Ruth turns a repressed widow into the show's funniest part
- David's story treats a closeted gay man as a lead, not a subplot, in 2001
- Thomas Newman's theme and the white-fade titles set the tone in a minute
What doesn’t
- The middle seasons lean on melodrama and repeat the same relationship fights
- Dream and fantasy sequences are overused once the novelty wears off
- Several characters are hard company for long stretches by design
The verdict
Six Feet Under is uneven in the way only an ambitious show can be. Its middle years repeat themselves, its fantasy scenes outstay their welcome and some of its people are trying company by design. Set against that is a family drawn with more honesty than almost anything else on television, an ensemble with no weak link, and a format that turns the most avoided subject there is into a source of comedy, tenderness and real insight. It earns its place among the essential HBO dramas of its era, and it ends better than nearly all of them. The score reflects a show whose highest peaks are as good as the form gets, held just short of the top tier by the stretch of road between them.





