Task · 2025
Task: a slow-burn crime drama that cares more about fathers than about cops
Task review. Brad Ingelsby's HBO crime drama sets Mark Ruffalo's grieving FBI agent against Tom Pelphrey's robber, and wins on character over plot.
Excellent
Editorial score out of 10
Task is a cop show in which the cops are the least interesting people on screen, and that is the best thing about it. Brad Ingelsby, who wrote Mare of Easttown, has built another story out of the small towns south-west of Philadelphia, and once again the investigation is the frame rather than the picture. What fills the picture is two men, an FBI agent and the man he is hunting, who are both trying to hold a household together with hands that are not quite steady enough for the job.
- 8.5
- Editorial score
- #40
- Of 109 series reviewed
- 2025
- Released
- 9.2
- Best at: Performances
The result is a slow, patient, frequently moving drama that asks for more patience than its marketing suggests. The opening episodes take their time, the procedural strand never quite earns its screen time, and the gang that drives the plot is drawn in broader strokes than anyone else. But the performances at its centre are as good as anything on television in 2025, and the show knows exactly what it is about.
The premise
Tom Brandis is an FBI agent who used to be a Catholic priest. When the series opens he has been away from fieldwork after a family tragedy, and his bosses hand him what looks like a punishment posting: a small task force in Delaware County, assembled to look into a string of armed robberies of drug houses. The houses belong to a motorcycle gang, the Dark Hearts, which means the victims are criminals and nobody local is in much of a hurry to help.
The robber, as the audience learns at once, is Robbie Prendergrast. He collects rubbish for a living, which is how he and his friend Cliff know which houses to hit and when. At home, his wife has left, and his niece Maeve has been left to raise his two young children in a cramped house where the bills arrive faster than the wages. In the first episode a job goes badly wrong, and what Robbie brings home from it turns a careful run of thefts into something that can no longer stay quiet. The show never pretends this is a mystery. It is a slow collision, and it tells you who is in each car.
Two men at two kitchen tables, each sure he is the one holding the family together.
That structure is the show's central idea. Tom and Robbie are rarely in the same room for most of the season, but the writing keeps placing them side by side: two men at kitchen tables, two men lying to children for their own good, two men whose sense of right and wrong has been bent by grief and money. Ingelsby is less interested in whether Tom will catch Robbie than in what each of them is prepared to lose along the way.

Structure and pace
Seven episodes of roughly an hour each is a sensible length for this story, and the season has a clear three-part shape: a long set-up, a tightening middle in which the task force and the gang close in from different directions, and a final stretch that brings the two halves together. The season tells a complete story. HBO first billed Task as a limited series before renewing it in November 2025, so there is no cliffhanger left dangling for the sake of a sequel.
The cost of that patience is paid up front. The first two episodes spend a great deal of time establishing households, routines and relationships before the plot begins to bite, and viewers expecting the pace of a conventional thriller may drift. The procedural side suffers most: Tom's team, including Fabien Frankel's eager county detective and Thuso Mbedu's no-nonsense detective sergeant from Chester, is sketched quickly and asked to carry exposition that the family scenes never need.
| Season | Year | Episodes | In one line |
|---|---|---|---|
| Season 1 | 2025 | 7 | Slow to start, then one of the year's most absorbing crime dramas |
| Season 2 | In production | — | Renewed in November 2025, filming from July 2026; no premiere date announced |
Once the season settles, though, the slowness turns into tension. By the middle episodes each new scene carries the weight of everything set up earlier, and small choices, a phone call not returned, a lie told to a child, land harder than any shoot-out. The gang subplot is the weak link here. Its leaders are more types than people, and the plotting around them borrows the familiar pieces of the genre, the suspicious lieutenant, the internal power struggle, without doing much new with them.
Characters
The show's real subject is family, and it spends most of its care on the people who live with Tom and Robbie. Maeve, Robbie's niece, is the clearest example. She is twenty-one and has been pushed into the role of a parent by circumstances she did not choose, and Emilia Jones plays her with a mixture of anger and tenderness that makes her as central as either lead. Tom's own household, quieter and more broken, is drawn with the same attention, and the scenes between him and his adopted daughter Emily are some of the most painful in the season.
The supporting cast around the two families is unusually deep for a crime series. Martha Plimpton has a handful of scenes as Kathleen, Tom's superior at the FBI, and makes every one of them count. Raúl Castillo's Cliff, Robbie's partner, is more than the loyal sidekick the role could have been. Even the minor members of the gang get moments that suggest lives beyond the plot. The exception, again, is the task force: next to the households on either side of the investigation, the investigators themselves feel like the least developed people in their own show.
How it measures up
- Pace
- 4/10
- Deliberate from the start; the first two hours are a test
- Plot density
- 6/10
- A simple chase made rich by the people in it
- Character depth
- 9/10
- Almost every household feels lived in
- Violence
- 6/10
- Rare, sudden and heavy when it comes
- Comfort viewing
- 2/10
- Grief and money worries in every room
Performances
Mark Ruffalo plays Tom as a man who has lost the knack of being in his own body. He moves slowly, speaks softly, and carries his faith, or what is left of it, like an injury he has learned to work around. It is an inward, unshowy performance, and the show trusts it enough to hold on his face for long silences.
Tom Pelphrey is the revelation. Robbie could easily have been the charming outlaw of a hundred crime films, and Pelphrey keeps finding the fear and the shame underneath the charm. He is funny with his children, frightening when cornered, and wholly believable as a man doing terrible things for reasons he half believes are good. When the two leads finally share the screen, the scenes play like the end of an argument the show has been building for hours.
Craft
Jeremiah Zagar and Salli Richardson-Whitfield split the directing, and they shoot Delaware County without varnish: back gardens, petrol stations, church halls and wooded edges of town, all in the muted greens and browns of late summer. The camera tends to stay close and still, which suits the material. Action is used sparingly, and when the violence arrives it is fast, chaotic and unglamorous.
Dan Deacon's score is understated, mostly low synthesisers and drones that sit under the scenes rather than telling the audience how to feel. The sound of the place, traffic, television, the noise of a house full of children, does as much work. Ingelsby's dialogue keeps the regional voice that made Mare of Easttown so specific, and the show is at its best when it lets characters talk around what they mean.
Where it sits
The obvious comparison is Ingelsby's own earlier series. Both are set in the same corner of Pennsylvania, both use an investigation as a way into a community, and both are carried by a star giving a performance stripped of vanity. Mare of Easttown is the tighter mystery; Task is the more ambitious character study, splitting its attention between hunter and hunted where Mare kept faith with one woman.
Head to head
- Craft
- 8.38.2
- Story
- 8.18.2
- Characters
- 8.88.8
- Performances
- 9.29.3
Task edges it by 0.1. See them side by side
Anyone who liked the first will find the same sensibility here, with a wider canvas and a heavier heart. Anyone who found that show too bleak should know that Task is darker still, and there is no detective in it with Mare's dry humour to lighten the load. Viewers coming from a faster crime series, such as The Pitt or a conventional thriller, should adjust their expectations about pace before the opening credits.
For you if
- Viewers who loved Mare of Easttown and wanted more of its people and places
- Anyone who prefers crime drama about consequences to crime drama about clues
- Admirers of Mark Ruffalo or Tom Pelphrey looking for career-best work
Not for you if
- Viewers who want a tight procedural with a puzzle to solve
- Anyone not in the mood for grief, guilt and children in danger
- Those who lose patience with two slow episodes before the plot moves
For anyone choosing between the two Ingelsby series, the earlier one is the gentler starting point and the better guide to whether this world is for you.
What works
- Ruffalo and Pelphrey play two halves of one argument about what a father owes
- Delaware County is drawn street by street, kitchen by kitchen, without postcard gloss
- Supporting roles, especially Emilia Jones as Maeve, get whole lives rather than functions
- Seven episodes with a clear shape, and a story that does close at the end of the season
What doesn’t
- The first two episodes move slowly enough to lose viewers who came for a thriller
- The task force itself is thinly sketched next to the families on either side of it
- The gang plotting leans on familiar crime-drama machinery in the middle stretch
The verdict
Task is not the thriller its premise promises, and it is better for it. The investigation is a frame for two portraits of fatherhood under strain, painted with enough care that the households of Delaware County linger long after the plot has resolved. Ruffalo and Pelphrey are outstanding, Emilia Jones nearly steals the season from both, and the final episodes justify the slow climb. The score is held below the top tier by a sluggish opening, a task force that never becomes as real as the families around it, and gang plotting that leans on old machinery. Those weaknesses are real, but they sit around the edges of a series whose centre is as strong as anything HBO aired in 2025.





