The Good Place · 2016
The Good Place: a sitcom about the afterlife that became a lesson in moral philosophy
The Good Place review: Michael Schur's NBC comedy is a joyfully inventive sitcom about ethics, redemption and friendship, led by Kristen Bell and Ted Danson.
Excellent
Editorial score out of 10
The Good Place is a network sitcom about death, ethics and the question of whether people can change. That sounds like a recipe for a worthy but tiresome comedy, yet Michael Schur's series is among the most inventive, surprising and genuinely funny comedies of its era. It uses the afterlife as a playground for philosophy, frozen yoghurt shops, profanity filters and some of the boldest plotting ever attempted in a half-hour format.
- 8.8
- Editorial score
- #22
- Of 109 series reviewed
- 2016
- Released
- 4
- Seasons
Its willingness to keep reinventing itself is thrilling, but not every reinvention works as well as the last. The result is a slightly uneven but consistently ambitious comedy that earns its reputation.
William Jackson Harper is superb as Chidi, whose paralysing indecision is both hilarious and poignant.
Story
The first season is a perfectly engineered puzzle. Eleanor's attempts to hide her flaws, learn about ethics and avoid detection produce a steady stream of jokes, while cleverly planted details lay the groundwork for developments that reshape the show. The less viewers know before starting, the better.
Subsequent seasons take the story in unexpected directions, and the writers are fearless about abandoning premises that another show might milk for years. That boldness produces brilliant episodes, but it also means some arcs feel hurried, with major changes happening in quick succession and the series pausing occasionally to explain its own increasingly complex rules. The final season carries the ideas to a thoughtful and moving conclusion.

Characters
Kristen Bell's Eleanor is a delightful mix of selfishness and scrappy intelligence, and her growth is handled with real care. Ted Danson is a joy as Michael, drawing on decades of comic experience to play an immortal being with a childlike fascination for human customs. William Jackson Harper is superb as Chidi, whose paralysing indecision is both hilarious and poignant.
D'Arcy Carden's Janet, an all-knowing assistant with an expanding range of emotions, is a comic tour de force, allowing Carden to play an astonishing variety of versions. Jameela Jamil's Tahani, a name-dropping socialite, and Manny Jacinto's Jason, a dim-witted amateur DJ from Florida, are frequently hilarious, though their characters can feel like vehicles for a single type of joke before later seasons deepen them.
Ideas and craft
The show's engagement with moral philosophy is its most distinctive feature. Kant, Aristotle, utilitarianism and T. M. Scanlon's What We Owe to Each Other are woven into the comedy with enough clarity for a general audience to follow, and the trolley problem episode is a masterpiece of absurdist teaching. Visually, the show is bright and colourful, with production design that makes its afterlife both idyllic and faintly unreal. Some effects are modest, but the design supports the tone well.
Who it is for
The Good Place is ideal for viewers who enjoy smart comedies with heart and serialised storytelling. It rewards bingeing from the start. Those who prefer traditional, standalone sitcoms may find the plotting complicated, while anyone averse to earnestness may be surprised by how emotional it becomes.
What works
- Weaves real moral philosophy into jokes without ever feeling like a lecture
- Bold structural reinventions keep the story consistently surprising
- D'Arcy Carden's Janet is one of the great sitcom inventions
- Its warmth and optimism are hard-won rather than sentimental
What doesn’t
- Middle seasons occasionally rush through reinventions and lose focus
- Some episodes lean too heavily on explaining its own rules
- Jason and Tahani can feel like one-note joke delivery systems
Head to head
- Craft
- 8.18.2
- Story
- 8.97.4
- Characters
- 9.08.8
- Performances
- 8.79.3
The Good Place edges it by 0.5. See them side by side
The verdict
The Good Place is a joyful, clever and humane comedy that uses big ideas to explore what it means to be good. Its restless plotting occasionally outpaces its focus, and a few characters take time to deepen, but its achievements are considerable. An 8.8 reflects a sitcom of rare ambition and warmth.





