Skip to content

Head to head

The Good Place vs What We Do in the Shadows

The Good Place takes it by 0.5, 8.8 against 8.3. The subscores below show where the gap actually is.

Cover of The Good Place
The Good Place

2016 · Excellent

  • Weaves real moral philosophy into jokes without ever feeling like a lecture
  • Bold structural reinventions keep the story consistently surprising
  • Middle seasons occasionally rush through reinventions and lose focus
Cover of What We Do in the Shadows
What We Do in the Shadows

2019 · Excellent

  • Matt Berry's plummy, bizarre line readings are endlessly quotable
  • Harvey Guillén's Guillermo gives the chaos a sympathetic human core
  • Later seasons recycle premises and start to feel like sketch collections

Where the gap is

Craft
8.18.2
Story
8.97.4
Characters
9.08.8
Performances
8.79.3

At a glance

FactThe Good PlaceWhat We Do in the Shadows
Released19 September 201627 March 2019
Created byMichael SchurJemaine Clement
StarringKristen Bell, Ted Danson, Jameela JamilKayvan Novak, Matt Berry, Natasia Demetriou
NetworkNBCFX
Seasons46
Episodes5361
GenreComedy · FantasyComedy · Fantasy · Horror

The two verdicts

The Good Place

The Good Place: a sitcom about the afterlife that became a lesson in moral philosophy

The Good Place is a joyful, clever and humane comedy that uses big ideas to explore what it means to be good. Its restless plotting occasionally outpaces its focus, and a few characters take time to deepen, but its achievements are considerable. An 8.8 reflects a sitcom of rare ambition and warmth.

Read the full review →

What We Do in the Shadows

What We Do in the Shadows: undead flatmates make for TV's silliest delight

What We Do in the Shadows is a consistently funny, inventive and charming comedy with an outstanding ensemble. Its later repetition and loose plotting keep it just short of the very top tier. An 8.3 reflects an excellent sitcom that made the undead feel gloriously alive.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.