What We Do in the Shadows · 2019
What We Do in the Shadows: undead flatmates make for TV's silliest delight
What We Do in the Shadows review: FX's vampire mockumentary, adapted from the film by Jemaine Clement and Taika Waititi, is a gloriously absurd comedy.
Excellent
Editorial score out of 10
What We Do in the Shadows takes a single, delicious premise, that ancient vampires are hopelessly out of touch with modern life, and wrings astonishing comic mileage from it. Adapted from Jemaine Clement and Taika Waititi's cult film, the series relocates the mockumentary format to Staten Island and assembles a cast of comic performers whose timing is impeccable. It is silly, inventive and frequently hilarious.
- 8.3
- Editorial score
- #51
- Of 109 series reviewed
- 2019
- Released
- 6
- Seasons
Across six seasons the show maintained a remarkably high hit rate, though its later years saw some repetition and loose storytelling. Even at its weakest, it remains one of the funniest comedies of its era.
Matt Berry's Laszlo is a triumph of plummy delivery and bizarre pronunciation, turning ordinary words into punchlines.
Story and format
Each episode typically follows the vampires as they attempt to navigate mundane modern challenges, from council meetings and nightclubs to online shopping, with disastrous results. Their centuries-old grandiosity clashes with suburban realities, and the documentary format lets them explain their bizarre logic to the camera. Longer arcs, such as the vampires' ambitions to conquer the New World or ascend within the vampire hierarchy, provide structure, but the show thrives on individual set pieces.
Standout episodes include On the Run, in which Laszlo hides from a vengeful rival under an absurd new identity in a small town, and the celebrity-filled vampire council gatherings. As the series progressed, some premises were revisited and the stakes grew less important, and Guillermo's quest to become a vampire, though often poignant, stalled in ways that frustrated some viewers.

Characters and performances
The cast is exceptional. Kayvan Novak's Nandor is a childlike former warlord whose emotional needs are both absurd and endearing. Matt Berry's Laszlo is a triumph of plummy delivery and bizarre pronunciation, turning ordinary words into punchlines. Natasia Demetriou's Nadja is fierce, dramatic and hilarious, her accent and passions a constant delight.
Mark Proksch is brilliant as Colin Robinson, whose monotonous small talk drains victims, and the character's later arcs showcase surprising range. Harvey Guillén gives Guillermo a warmth and frustration that ground the show, and his relationship with Nandor gives the series its emotional backbone. Kristen Schaal's scene-stealing Guide becomes a welcome regular.
Craft
The mockumentary format is used cleverly, with nervous glances at the camera, mistimed zooms and crew members occasionally dragged into the chaos. The production design, from the vampires' cluttered gothic mansion to their extravagant costumes, is delightful, and the effects, including bats, flying and gory mishaps, are deliberately scrappy yet effective. The show's use of guest stars, particularly in its council episodes, adds to its sense of anarchic fun.
Who it is for
What We Do in the Shadows will appeal to fans of absurd comedy, mockumentaries and horror parodies. Knowledge of the original film is not required. Viewers seeking tightly plotted storytelling may find its loose structure less satisfying, but most comedy fans will find plenty to love.
What works
- Matt Berry's plummy, bizarre line readings are endlessly quotable
- Harvey Guillén's Guillermo gives the chaos a sympathetic human core
- Colin Robinson's energy-vampire concept is a brilliant comic invention
- Standalone episodes such as On the Run are near-perfect sitcom farce
What doesn’t
- Later seasons recycle premises and start to feel like sketch collections
- Guillermo's long-running arc stalls repeatedly across the seasons
- Loose continuity means plotlines are dropped with little payoff
Head to head
- Craft
- 8.28.1
- Story
- 7.48.9
- Characters
- 8.89.0
- Performances
- 9.38.7
The Good Place edges it by 0.5. See them side by side
The verdict
What We Do in the Shadows is a consistently funny, inventive and charming comedy with an outstanding ensemble. Its later repetition and loose plotting keep it just short of the very top tier. An 8.3 reflects an excellent sitcom that made the undead feel gloriously alive.





