The Penguin · 2024
The Penguin: Colin Farrell turns a Batman villain into a gripping crime tragedy
The Penguin review: HBO's Gotham crime saga, led by a transformed Colin Farrell and a superb Cristin Milioti, is a gritty, character-driven gangster drama.
Excellent
Editorial score out of 10
Spin-offs built around supporting villains rarely carry much promise, but The Penguin is a striking exception. Taking Colin Farrell's small, scene-stealing role from The Batman, Lauren LeFranc's series constructs a gritty crime saga that owes more to The Sopranos and classic gangster cinema than to superhero franchises. Batman himself is absent, allowing the show to explore Gotham's underworld on its own terms.
- 8.4
- Editorial score
- #46
- Of 109 series reviewed
- 2024
- Released
- 1
- Seasons
The result is one of the strongest comic book adaptations on television, powered by two exceptional performances. Its plotting is occasionally predictable, but its craft and character work are exceptional.
Cristin Milioti is equally remarkable as Sofia Falcone, a woman whose years in Arkham have left her with scores to settle.
Story
The series begins with a power vacuum. Carmine Falcone is dead, the city is recovering from catastrophe, and rival crime families are circling. Oz Cobb, long dismissed as a mere driver and fixer, launches a daring bid for power, recruiting Victor Aguilar, a teenager left adrift by the flood, as his reluctant accomplice. The story is less about spectacle than about ambition, class resentment and the brutal pragmatism required to climb.
The show is at its best when its characters collide. A standout episode devoted to Sofia's backstory, detailing her time in Arkham and her family's secrets, is among the finest hours of television that year. The middle episodes, however, occasionally slow as alliances and betrayals are rearranged, and Victor's arc follows a fairly predictable path.

Characters and performances
Colin Farrell is unrecognisable beneath prosthetics by Mike Marino, but the performance is far more than makeup. His Oz is charming, pathetic, cunning and terrifying, a man whose hunger for respect is rooted in childhood humiliation. Farrell captures the character's desperation and menace without softening his cruelty.
Cristin Milioti is equally remarkable as Sofia Falcone, a woman whose years in Arkham have left her with scores to settle. Milioti's performance moves from brittle composure to fierce rage and deep vulnerability, and her rivalry with Oz drives the show. Rhenzy Feliz gives Victor a tender awkwardness, while Deirdre O'Connell is haunting as Francis, Oz's ailing mother. Clancy Brown's Sal Maroni adds imposing gravitas.
Craft
The Penguin maintains the grimy, rain-soaked aesthetic of The Batman, presenting Gotham as a decaying metropolis of flooded streets, nightclubs and industrial wastelands. The cinematography favours dark, moody lighting and grounded locations, and the production design emphasises realism over comic book flourish. Mick Giacchino's score, echoing themes from The Batman, adds a brooding intensity. The violence is visceral and consequential.
Who it is for
The Penguin will appeal to fans of crime dramas and of Matt Reeves's Batman universe, but it requires no knowledge of the film beyond its basic premise. It particularly suits viewers who enjoy character studies and gangster stories. Those expecting superhero action will find it more akin to a mob drama.
What works
- Colin Farrell disappears completely into Oz Cobb's menace and neediness
- Cristin Milioti's Sofia Falcone is a ferocious, heartbreaking creation
- Treats its comic book world with the grit of a classic mob drama
- Deirdre O'Connell makes Oz's mother a haunting, complicated figure
What doesn’t
- Middle episodes slow noticeably as gang politics are rearranged
- Victor's storyline follows a fairly predictable trajectory
- The absence of Batman leaves some of Gotham's wider stakes vague
Head to head
- Craft
- 8.88.2
- Story
- 8.08.2
- Characters
- 8.88.8
- Performances
- 9.39.3
Dead level: both score 8.4.See them side by side
The verdict
The Penguin is a gripping, superbly acted crime saga that elevates its comic book origins through rich characterisation and grounded craft. Its occasional pacing lulls and predictable subplot keep it from true greatness. An 8.4 reflects a compelling series powered by two of the best performances of its year.





