Skip to content
Movie reviewGood

The Shape of Water · 2017

The Shape of Water: del Toro's Cold War fairy tale swoons, if predictably

The Shape of Water review: Guillermo del Toro's romance between a mute cleaner and an amphibian creature is lush and heartfelt, if simply drawn.

Voxizer EditorialSection editor David Abellán3 min read

Good

Editorial score out of 10

The Shape of Water is Guillermo del Toro's most romantic film: a lush, heartfelt fairy tale that combines Cold War espionage, classic monster movies and an unconventional love story. It is made with enormous affection for outsiders, old Hollywood and the power of empathy, and its visual and musical craftsmanship are exceptional.

7.9
Editorial score
#90
Of 112 movies reviewed
2017
Released
9.2
Best at: Craft

It is also a very simple story, with clearly drawn heroes and villains. Its sincerity is charming, but its familiar plot and broad characterisation make it less rich than del Toro's finest work.

Its sincerity is charming, but its familiar plot and broad characterisation make it less rich than del Toro's finest work.

Story

Elisa lives a solitary, routine life in an apartment above a cinema. Her closest friends are her neighbour Giles, a lonely, closeted illustrator, and her colleague Zelda, who talks enough for both of them. When the laboratory receives a creature taken from a river in South America, Elisa is fascinated. She begins visiting him secretly, sharing boiled eggs, music and sign language.

Strickland, a sadistic security officer, sees the creature as nothing more than an asset, while Dr Hoffstetler, a scientist with a hidden agenda, argues for studying it. As the government considers dissecting the creature, Elisa devises a plan with the help of her friends. The film's themes of loneliness, marginalisation and love beyond appearances are expressed clearly and warmly. However, the plot unfolds much as viewers might expect, and the espionage subplot sometimes feels like a device to create obstacles.

Direction and craft

Del Toro's direction is elegant and deeply personal. The production design is extraordinary, with a palette of teal, green and amber that makes the laboratory, Elisa's apartment and rainy Baltimore streets feel both realistic and magical. Dan Laustsen's cinematography uses fluid camera movement and soft lighting to create a dreamy atmosphere.

The creature design is superb, combining prosthetics and digital enhancements to create a being who is both alien and expressive. Alexandre Desplat's score, which won an Academy Award, is gentle and lilting, full of whistling, accordion and waltz rhythms. A black-and-white fantasy sequence, in which Elisa imagines herself singing and dancing, is a lovely homage to classic Hollywood musicals. The film does occasionally over-emphasise its symbolism, including water imagery and references to cinema.

Performances

Sally Hawkins is wonderful as Elisa. Without speaking, she conveys joy, desire, frustration and courage through her expressive face and signing. Her performance gives the film its emotional core, and her chemistry with Doug Jones's creature is surprisingly convincing.

Doug Jones, a veteran of creature performances, brings grace and personality to the amphibian man. Richard Jenkins is superb as Giles, a gentle, melancholy figure whose loneliness mirrors Elisa's. Octavia Spencer adds humour and warmth as Zelda, and Michael Stuhlbarg is compelling as Hoffstetler. Michael Shannon is intimidating as Strickland, but the character is so overtly monstrous that he lacks complexity.

Who it is for

The Shape of Water is for viewers who enjoy fantasy romance, visually rich filmmaking and stories that celebrate outsiders. Fans of del Toro and of classic cinema will appreciate its many homages. It contains nudity, sexual content and violence, so despite its fairy-tale quality it is not aimed at children.

What works

  • Sally Hawkins gives a wordless, expressive and deeply touching lead role
  • Rich teal-and-green production design creates a gorgeous storybook world
  • Alexandre Desplat's lilting, waltz-like score is gently enchanting
  • Warm supporting turns from Richard Jenkins and Octavia Spencer

What doesn’t

  • Michael Shannon's Strickland is a one-dimensional villain
  • The plot follows a predictable fairy-tale course with few surprises
  • Some heavy-handed symbolism undercuts the film's delicacy

Head to head

Craft
9.29.4
Story
7.18.5
Direction
8.69.2
Performances
8.59.4

Phantom Thread edges it by 0.9. See them side by side

GoodHow we score

The verdict

The Shape of Water is a beautifully crafted, sincere and emotionally warm film that won Best Picture and many other honours. Sally Hawkins's performance and the film's lovely design make it a delight. Its predictable plot, one-dimensional villain and heavy symbolism, however, keep it from the heights of del Toro's most layered work, placing it among the good rather than the great.

Quick answers

Is The Shape of Water worth watching?

Voxizer scores The Shape of Water (2017) 7.9 out of 10 — good. The Shape of Water is a beautifully crafted, sincere and emotionally warm film that won Best Picture and many other honours. Sally Hawkins's performance and the film's lovely design make it a delight.

What readers say

Written by Voxizer members and checked by our moderators before they appear.

Written reviews

–

No written reviews yet

Write a review
9–10
0
7–8.5
0
5–6.5
0
3–4.5
0
0–2.5
0

Nobody has reviewed The Shape of Water yet. Be the first.

All reviews →

Verified sources

Published by the Voxizer editorial team — David Abellán, Ignacio Pineda, Pablo Huguet. Section editor for movies: David Abellán.

Revision history

  1. Published

Scores are revised when the facts behind them change, and the change is recorded here. How we score.