Skip to content

Head to head

Phantom Thread vs The Shape of Water

Phantom Thread takes it by 0.9, 8.8 against 7.9. The subscores below show where the gap actually is.

Cover of Phantom Thread
Phantom Thread

2017 · Excellent

  • Daniel Day-Lewis makes a fastidious, petulant genius oddly magnetic
  • Vicky Krieps holds her own as Alma, steadily shifting the balance of power
  • Its languid pace and chilly surface can feel airless to some viewers
Cover of The Shape of Water
The Shape of Water

2017 · Good

  • Sally Hawkins gives a wordless, expressive and deeply touching lead role
  • Rich teal-and-green production design creates a gorgeous storybook world
  • Michael Shannon's Strickland is a one-dimensional villain

Where the gap is

Craft
9.49.2
Story
8.57.1
Direction
9.28.6
Performances
9.48.5

At a glance

FactPhantom ThreadThe Shape of Water
Released25 December 20171 December 2017
DirectorPaul Thomas AndersonGuillermo del Toro
StarringDaniel Day-Lewis, Lesley Manville, Vicky KriepsSally Hawkins, Michael Shannon, Octavia Spencer
Runtime130 minutes123 minutes
StudioAnnapurna PicturesSearchlight Pictures, TSG Entertainment
GenreDrama · RomanceDrama · Fantasy · Romance

The two verdicts

Phantom Thread

Phantom Thread: an exquisitely tailored romance with a wicked sense of humour

Phantom Thread is a gorgeously made, superbly acted film that grows richer with each viewing, and it was widely admired as one of Anderson's most refined works. Its deliberately limited scope and unsettling central relationship will not suit every taste, and its tempo can feel stately to a fault. Still, it is a near-flawless piece of craftsmanship and an unforgettable portrait of an unconventional love.

Read the full review →

The Shape of Water

The Shape of Water: del Toro's Cold War fairy tale swoons, if predictably

The Shape of Water is a beautifully crafted, sincere and emotionally warm film that won Best Picture and many other honours. Sally Hawkins's performance and the film's lovely design make it a delight. Its predictable plot, one-dimensional villain and heavy symbolism, however, keep it from the heights of del Toro's most layered work, placing it among the good rather than the great.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.