The Umbrella Academy · 2019
The Umbrella Academy: a fun, dysfunctional superhero family that ran out of ideas
The Umbrella Academy review: Netflix's adaptation of Gerard Way and Gabriel Bá's comic starts as a quirky superhero delight but loses its way in later seasons.
Mixed
Editorial score out of 10
The Umbrella Academy arrived in 2019 as a welcome alternative to glossy superhero franchises. Based on a comic by My Chemical Romance frontman Gerard Way and artist Gabriel Bá, it presented a family of damaged, bickering adults with extraordinary abilities, a talking chimpanzee butler, a robot mother and a thirteen-year-old body housing a middle-aged assassin. The first season's mix of melancholy, violence and absurd humour was irresistible.
- 6.7
- Editorial score
- #103
- Of 109 series reviewed
- 2019
- Released
- 4
- Seasons
Across four seasons, though, the show struggled to build on that promise. Its reliance on repeated apocalyptic scenarios and increasingly convoluted mechanics made it feel less inventive over time.
The Umbrella Academy is stylish, with bold colours, inventive fight choreography and a soundtrack full of surprising song choices.
Story
The first season follows the siblings' reunion after their adoptive father's death and their race to prevent a looming catastrophe. It skilfully balances family drama with a mystery, and the gradual revelation of the siblings' childhood traumas gives the action emotional weight. The season's use of time travel adds intrigue while remaining relatively clear.
The second season, set in 1960s Dallas, offers a vibrant change of scenery and some of the show's strongest character work. The third introduces a rival superhero team and a more cosmic threat, and the formula of racing against the end of the world starts to wear thin. The fourth and final season, shorter than its predecessors, was widely criticised for rushed storytelling and an underwhelming resolution.

Characters and performances
The show's appeal lies largely in its cast. Aidan Gallagher is excellent as Number Five, bringing dry wit and weary gravitas to a character stuck in a younger body. Robert Sheehan's Klaus, a drug-addled medium who can communicate with the dead, is both hilarious and heartbreaking. Tom Hopper gives Luther a lovable vulnerability, and David Castañeda makes Diego's bravado charming.
Emmy Raver-Lampman brings grace and complexity to Allison, whose power to manipulate others with rumours raises moral questions. Elliot Page's portrayal of Viktor, the overlooked sibling long kept on the sidelines of the team, provides emotional depth. Justin H. Min's Ben is a quiet highlight. The ensemble's chemistry often compensates for weaker writing, although some characters, notably Luther and Diego, are given repetitive arcs.
Craft
The Umbrella Academy is stylish, with bold colours, inventive fight choreography and a soundtrack full of surprising song choices. Memorable moments, such as a family dance set to a pop classic in the first season, capture its offbeat spirit. The visual effects are generally strong, though later seasons rely increasingly on elaborate set pieces that do not always compensate for narrative weaknesses.
Who it is for
The Umbrella Academy will appeal to viewers who enjoy quirky, dark superhero stories and dysfunctional family dramas. It is particularly suited to fans of irreverent genre television. Those seeking tight plotting or satisfying conclusions may find the later seasons frustrating.
What works
- Aidan Gallagher's world-weary Number Five is a sharp comic creation
- Robert Sheehan brings chaotic pathos to the troubled Klaus
- Imaginative needle drops and dance sequences give it real personality
- The sibling dynamics are messy, funny and often affecting
What doesn’t
- Repeated apocalypse-averting plots grow formulaic across seasons
- The short final season was widely seen as a disappointing conclusion
- Time-travel rules become confusing and inconsistent
Head to head
- Craft
- 7.38.1
- Story
- 6.07.6
- Characters
- 7.28.3
- Performances
- 7.68.8
The Boys edges it by 1.3. See them side by side
The verdict
The Umbrella Academy began as a lively, emotionally resonant take on the superhero genre, powered by an engaging cast and distinctive style. Its repetitive story structures, confusing mechanics and disappointing final season diminish its overall impact. A 6.7 reflects a mixed series whose early promise was never fully realised.





