Skip to content

Head to head

The Boys vs The Umbrella Academy

The Boys takes it by 1.3, 8.0 against 6.7. The subscores below show where the gap actually is.

Cover of The Boys
The Boys

2019 · Excellent

  • Antony Starr's Homelander is one of television's most frightening villains
  • Satire of corporate branding and celebrity culture hits hard and often
  • Escalating gross-out moments become repetitive rather than shocking
Cover of The Umbrella Academy
  • Aidan Gallagher's world-weary Number Five is a sharp comic creation
  • Robert Sheehan brings chaotic pathos to the troubled Klaus
  • Repeated apocalypse-averting plots grow formulaic across seasons

Where the gap is

Craft
8.17.3
Story
7.66.0
Characters
8.37.2
Performances
8.87.6

At a glance

FactThe BoysThe Umbrella Academy
Released26 July 201915 February 2019
Created byEric Kripke, Evan GoldbergSteve Blackman
StarringKarl Urban, Elisabeth Shue, Erin MoriartyElliot Page, Tom Hopper, David Castaneda
NetworkAmazon Prime VideoNetflix
Seasons44
Episodes3236
GenreAction · Sci-Fi · ComedyAction · Adventure · Comedy

The two verdicts

The Boys

The Boys: a gleefully vicious superhero satire that sometimes mistakes shock for insight

The Boys has been one of the most distinctive superhero series of its era, with a towering villain, sharp early satire and an excellent cast. Its later seasons are messier, more repetitive and less subtle, even as they remain entertaining. An 8.0 reflects a bold, often brilliant series that has occasionally let excess do the work of ideas.

Read the full review →

The Umbrella Academy

The Umbrella Academy: a fun, dysfunctional superhero family that ran out of ideas

The Umbrella Academy began as a lively, emotionally resonant take on the superhero genre, powered by an engaging cast and distinctive style. Its repetitive story structures, confusing mechanics and disappointing final season diminish its overall impact. A 6.7 reflects a mixed series whose early promise was never fully realised.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.