Skip to content

Head to head

Alien: Romulus vs The Whale

Alien: Romulus takes it by 0.4, 7.1 against 6.7. The subscores below show where the gap actually is.

Cover of Alien: Romulus
Alien: Romulus

2024 · Good

  • Practical creature work and sets give the horror real physical weight
  • David Jonsson is excellent as the vulnerable synthetic Andy
  • Constant callbacks and repeated lines feel like franchise box-ticking
Cover of The Whale
The Whale

2022 · Mixed

  • Brendan Fraser gives a warm, vulnerable and deeply felt lead performance
  • Hong Chau is excellent as Liz, a friend whose care is tangled with anger
  • Heavy-handed, melodramatic writing pushes hard for tears

Where the gap is

Craft
8.46.9
Story
6.26.0
Direction
7.66.3
Performances
7.48.6

At a glance

FactAlien: RomulusThe Whale
Released16 August 20249 December 2022
DirectorFede ÁlvarezDarren Aronofsky
StarringCailee Spaeny, Isabela Merced, David JonssonBrendan Fraser, Hong Chau, Sadie Sink
Runtime119 minutes117 minutes
StudioBrandywine Productions, Scott Free ProductionsProtozoa Pictures
GenreAction · Sci-Fi · HorrorDrama

The two verdicts

Alien: Romulus

Alien: Romulus is a slick, scary return to basics that leans too hard on nostalgia

Alien: Romulus is a capable, frequently scary genre film with superb practical craft and one excellent performance. It also plays it too safe, mistaking reference for reverence and populating its story with characters who rarely rise above archetypes. Fans will find much to enjoy, which is why it scores a respectable 7.1, but it lands well short of the originals it so openly admires.

Read the full review →

The Whale

The Whale: Brendan Fraser's great performance, trapped inside a heavy film

The Whale features a remarkable, humane central performance and a strong supporting turn from Hong Chau, but it is weighed down by melodramatic writing, a stagy structure and a troubling approach to its subject. Fraser's work gives it real emotional force, yet the film around him is too heavy-handed to be more than a mixed success.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.