Skip to content

Head to head

Baby Reindeer vs The Eternaut

Dead level: both score 8.3. What separates them is what they are for, not how good they are.

Cover of Baby Reindeer
Baby Reindeer

2024 · Excellent

  • Jessica Gunning makes Martha frightening, funny and pitiable at once
  • Gadd refuses to cast himself as a blameless victim
  • Heavy voiceover sometimes tells what the images already show
Cover of The Eternaut
The Eternaut

2025 · Excellent

  • Buenos Aires is specific down to the street names, the cars and the card games
  • Ricardo Darín plays Juan Salvo as a tired, capable man rather than an action hero
  • The season stops halfway through the story, with the concluding season still to come

Where the gap is

Craft
8.08.6
Story
8.47.9
Characters
8.68.4
Performances
9.38.9

At a glance

FactBaby ReindeerThe Eternaut
Released11 April 202430 April 2025
Created byRichard GaddBruno Stagnaro
StarringRichard Gadd, Jessica Gunning, Nava MauRicardo Darín, César Troncoso, Carla Peterson
NetworkNetflixNetflix
Seasons11 (a second, final season announced)
Episodes76
GenreDrama · Black comedy · SuspenseSci-Fi · Drama · Thriller

The two verdicts

Baby Reindeer

Baby Reindeer: a raw, brave confession that is hard to watch and harder to forget

Baby Reindeer scores 8.3 for the courage of its writing, two exceptional central performances and a fourth episode that ranks among the most powerful hours of recent drama. Its overused narration, looser final stretch and the unresolved ethical questions raised by its true-story framing keep it from a higher mark, but it is essential viewing for anyone interested in how television can confront trauma.

Read the full review →

The Eternaut

The Eternaut: an alien invasion told from a card table in the Buenos Aires suburbs

The Eternaut is the rare streaming adaptation that trusts its source's local identity rather than sanding it down for export, and that trust is what makes it distinctive. The opening episodes are as tense as anything the genre has produced recently, built from snow, silence and a house full of frightened friends, and Darín leads an ensemble that makes the collective hero feel like a lived idea rather than a slogan. The score stops short of the top tier because the middle of the season stalls, the creature work trails the rest of the craft, and the story is only half told. If the second season lands, this first one will look like the patient set-up it was meant to be; on its own, it is an excellent, unfinished beginning.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.