Skip to content

Head to head

Barry vs Gomorrah

Dead level: both score 8.7. What separates them is what they are for, not how good they are.

Cover of Barry
Barry

2018 · Excellent

  • Bill Hader's direction grows startlingly confident and inventive
  • Henry Winkler and Anthony Carrigan give unforgettable performances
  • The final season's bleakness squeezes out much of the humour
Cover of Gomorrah
Gomorrah

2014 · Excellent

  • Neapolitan dialogue and real Scampia locations make every scene feel lived in
  • Marco D'Amore and Salvatore Esposito build a partnership the whole show turns on
  • With no one decent to follow, some viewers will find it hard to care who wins

Where the gap is

Craft
9.29.1
Story
8.58.5
Characters
8.98.9
Performances
9.39.0

At a glance

FactBarryGomorrah
Released25 March 20186 May 2014
Created byBill Hader, Alec BergRoberto Saviano, Stefano Bises
StarringBill Hader, Stephen Root, Sarah GoldbergMarco D'Amore, Salvatore Esposito, Fortunato Cerlino
NetworkHBOSky Atlantic (Italy)
Seasons45
Episodes3258
GenreDrama · Comedy · CrimeDrama · Thriller · Crime

The two verdicts

Barry

Barry: a hitman comedy that turned, brilliantly, into a study of guilt

Barry earns an 8.7 for outstanding performances, directing that grows more inventive with every season, and the seriousness with which it treats its central moral question. The final season's relentless gloom and a few rushed turns keep it from the very top rank, but few comedies have ever evolved so fearlessly into something so much deeper.

Read the full review →

Gomorrah

Gomorrah: a crime saga that gives you no one to root for, and dares you to look away

Gomorrah is a crime series with the courage of its subject. It never asks the viewer to admire the people it follows, it never pretends the trade they run is anything other than squalid, and it builds a world so specific in language, architecture and sound that it feels reported rather than invented. The two central performances hold it together from first episode to last. The score stops short of the top tier because the later seasons fall into a rhythm a viewer can anticipate, and because the show's refusal of any outside perspective, admirable as principle, can leave it airless across five seasons. For a viewer willing to meet it on its terms, it is still the most important European crime drama of its decade.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.