Skip to content

Head to head

Blankets vs The Nice House on the Lake

Dead level: both score 8.6. What separates them is what they are for, not how good they are.

Cover of Blankets
Blankets

2003 · Excellent

  • Brush drawing that turns snow, quilts and blank space into the book's real language
  • The brothers' shared childhood bed gives the whole memoir its emotional anchor
  • Raina is seen almost entirely through Craig's longing and stays partly out of focus
Cover of The Nice House on the Lake
  • A first issue that turns a holiday into a trap in a handful of pages
  • Martínez Bueno draws the house so lovingly that its comfort becomes the threat
  • Some of the guests get far less room than the cast list promises

Where the gap is

Art
9.49.4
Story
8.38.4
Pacing
7.97.7
Characters
8.48.1

At a glance

FactBlanketsThe Nice House on the Lake
Released23 July 20031 June 2021
WriterCraig ThompsonJames Tynion IV
ArtistCraig ThompsonÁlvaro Martínez Bueno, Jordie Bellaire
PublisherTop Shelf Productions, Drawn & QuarterlyDC Comics
IssuesOne volume, an original graphic novel not serialised beforehand12 issues (June 2021 – December 2022)
GenreRomance · Graphic Novel · Coming of ageSci-Fi · Drama · Horror

The two verdicts

Blankets

Blankets: a memoir of first love whose drawings say what its words cannot

*Blankets* is one of the books that showed what an American graphic novel about ordinary life could look like, and it still looks extraordinary. Thompson's drawing turns snow, sheets and silence into a vocabulary of feeling, and his account of a boy outgrowing the faith that formed him is fair to everyone involved, including the boy. The score stops short of the top tier for reasons the book itself makes visible: a middle stretch that lingers longer than its story needs, and a first love who remains more an image than a person. Those limits are real, and they are the limits of memory itself. For readers willing to move at its pace, it is a deeply rewarding book, and one that is easy to return to every few winters.

Read the full review →

The Nice House on the Lake

The Nice House on the Lake: an apocalypse told as a weekend away with old friends

*The Nice House on the Lake* is a horror comic that understands what is frightening about being looked after by someone who has decided what is good for you. Martínez Bueno's art and Bellaire's colour make the house the most memorable setting in recent mainstream comics, and Walter is a villain, if that is the word, unlike any other. The score is held back by a cast that is larger than the series can fully serve and a middle stretch that explains when it should unsettle. Read in collected form, with the break between halves removed, those problems shrink, and what remains is a confident, unusual piece of horror that earns its reputation.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.