Skip to content

Head to head

Bloodborne vs Dark Souls

Dark Souls takes it by 0.1, 9.4 against 9.3. The subscores below show where the gap actually is.

Cover of Bloodborne
Bloodborne

2015 · Essential

  • Rally system turns every fight into a deliberate act of aggression
  • Trick weapons are inventive, flexible and a pleasure to master
  • Uneven frame pacing and the lack of a modern update hurt it today
Cover of Dark Souls
Dark Souls

2011 · Essential

  • A world that folds back on itself through brilliant shortcuts
  • Deliberate, weighty combat that rewards patience and observation
  • Later areas feel rushed and markedly less refined

Where the gap is

Story
9.09.1
Gameplay
9.69.5
Longevity
8.89.3
Presentation
9.28.6

At a glance

FactBloodborneDark Souls
Released24 March 201522 September 2011
DeveloperFromSoftware, Japan StudioFromSoftware
PublisherSony Interactive EntertainmentNamco Bandai Games America, FromSoftware
PlatformsPlayStation 4PC (Windows), PlayStation 3
DirectorHidetaka MiyazakiHidetaka Miyazaki
EngineCustomCustom
GenreAction · RPG · SoulslikeAction · RPG · Soulslike

The two verdicts

Bloodborne

Bloodborne is FromSoftware's most focused, feverish and aggressive nightmare

Bloodborne earns an exceptional score for its peerless combat design, brilliant world and deeply unsettling atmosphere. Technical limitations, weak optional dungeons and narrower build variety keep it just below all-time landmark status, but as a distilled expression of what FromSoftware does best, it remains extraordinary.

Read the full review →

Dark Souls

Dark Souls: the interlocking masterpiece that taught a generation to persevere

Dark Souls earns an exceptional score for its extraordinary world design, its influential combat and its approach to storytelling. A rushed second half and some technical roughness keep it a fraction short of perfection, but its importance and its enduring quality make it one of the essential games of all time.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.